Sheetz of Hilliard is a 24/7 convenience store that offers a wide range of products, from award-winning Made-To-Order food and hand-crafted Sheetz Bros. Coffeez drinks to packaged snacks, drinks, tobacco, and CBD products. Customers praise the store's delicious food, cheap gas, and free air for tires. The bathrooms are also noted for being clean. While some customers find the food to be just "okay" or "mediocre," others enjoy the value and friendly staff, particularly the helpful service from Caitlin. Overall, Sheetz provides a kicked-up convenience experience for its customers.
It didn't seem dirty here, I'll update if I need the bathroom what those look like.
Has anyone ever seen a happy Sheetz employee?
January 2026
Not overly impressed with this location. Floors dirty, outside trash overflowing at almost every pump. Could be cleaner overall.
August 2025
Just stopped in with a group of boys, who were hot after volunteering for the Special Olympics. All of them got a slushy. We went up to pay and the lady at the register thanked them all for their hard work and bought their slushees for them.
