Cartridge Gaming is a hidden gem in Lima, located next to Rapid Fire Pizza. It is a favorite go-to game store with a great selection of retro gaming and older but good systems, complete with a lot of the games to go with them. The store has an awesome variety of stuff, including old games and toys, and incredible deals for Magic: The Gathering. It is a great place for getting started collecting or for finding more cards.
The people that run the place provide great customer service. The staff is super friendly, very helpful, and will stop and chat. They are great with negotiating prices and saving items for customers if asked. Multiple customers have had consoles fixed and cleaned there with great results. The prices are very fair and reasonable, with owners sometimes throwing in freebies.
Families enjoy stopping by, with many noting they could get lost for hours playing pinball on the 20+ machines. With around $10 and decent skills, you can get a solid hour of play time. It is the kind of store that needs to stick around, and many customers choose it over other chain stores, driving from out of town to return again and again.
THIS PLACE IS SUCH A HIDDEN GEM!!! 50 cent stress relief! This place is so fun to just pop in & play a couple old school pinball or arcade games. Most pinball machines are $.50/3balls. They have my favorite too - SKEEBALL!!! And they have great evening hours! SO FUN!
July 2026
Went for the first time tonight and gotta say , as somebody who's always looking for atari games they had the most ive seen at any game store in a long time. I also appreciate that they cleaned the games and everything for me before I purchased them which ive never had a store do before. Ill definitely be back to buy more!
July 2026
Amazing!!! I hope Lima never loses this store ! One of Limas diamonds in its ruff ! I maybe biased or it maybe because it's a one of a kind store in Lima, but it's still a GREAT place to go !