Logan Goodwill is a nice small store where nice things can be found and the selection is fairly decent, though disorganized. Reviews note that staff can be very nice, helpful, and friendly. However, multiple customers feel prices are higher than they should be, stating clothes are overpriced for used items, with used jeans priced at $6.99, $8.99, or more. Some find most prices fair but note some items lack price tags. The selection is also described as one-third what it was at the prior location in town. The store is criticized for being very unclean, with grimy clothes and unkept floors, and for having no ability to try on items. While some would definitely come back, others state the thrill of finding a bargain is a thing of the past and that they will drive to other thrift stores with lower prices instead.