Plato’s Closet Lyndhurst is a locally owned resale store that offers gently used trendy clothes, shoes, jewelry, and more for teens, twenty-somethings, and anyone looking for a good deal. The store buys clothing in all seasons, paying cash for items they can sell. Customers appreciate the friendly and welcoming staff, who are consistently nice and helpful, making shopping and selling experience positive. Many mention the store's great selection of trendy, affordable clothing, including brands like Lululemon, with some noting that prices can be higher but still often better than regular retail. The store frequently has a variety of new styles and remains a favorite spot for those seeking fashionable second-hand clothes at lower prices. Customers also value the positive energy of the staff, with some inspired by their kindness. While some mention that the prices are rising slightly, the store still offers good deals, like finding jeans for a fraction of their original price. The store accepts a wide range of items, though shoppers are advised to bring a bag for their purchases, as the store no longer provides them. Overall, Plato’s Closet Lyndhurst is known for its friendly atmosphere, trendy selection, and affordability, making it a popular choice for those shopping second-hand or selling their clothes.
Always tons of great clothes. Prices are reasonable considering the quality. I love this store.
November 2025
More variety than other second-hand stores in the large and extra-large sizes.
September 2025
Even during off hours, this store is clean and efficient. A bag of clothes that we brought in to sell was processed within 20 minutes, and the staff were very pleasant and friendly. I really don't like used clothing stores, but we had a good experience here.
