Thrift Stores near Lyndhurst, OH

18 locations found near Lyndhurst

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 5688 Mayfield Road, Lyndhurst OH 44124

    3.6 Good 217 reviews

    “I had a great experience there !! Wait was about 40 minutes like they said it would. The lady who helped me was very friendly and explained everything I need to know. They made me a great offer for some of my close and overall it went very pleasant! I will be back for sure !”

  2. 6383 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights OH 44124

    4.7 Superb 156 reviews

    “- [ ] Had an awesome experience here! Right when I came in they gave me a heads up about extended wait. The check in process was super straightforward, made for a great start! The store itself is quite nice and very well thought out. In the evening I got a text saying the items were ready. I asked if I could come in the next day, and the automated system sent a message saying they didn’t pick any of my items. I was bummed and went back the next day, they once again were super kind, I showed them the message, they were super understanding, apologized for the confusion and mentioned they would follow up. I wish I had gotten their names, they were super helpful and so kind explaining everything with the offer. I thought the offer was good, much better than comparing services such as Plato’s Closet. It was something around 20 dollars for three older but in fashion items. They have a service to donate, but are also happy to keep the clothes to give back to the customer. Overall a great experience, and although I didn’t buy anything this time I thought the items were fairly priced, and they had lots of great brands such as Aritzia, Lululemon, and Brandy Melville. Overall a great place, and I will definitely be back!”

  3. 616 East 185th Street, Cleveland OH 44119

    4.9 Superb 33 reviews

    “My daughter has been going here for over 3 years and I have seen amazing improvements. She has increased her reading and math scores. She has earned Merit Roll for these last 3 years and I am so pleased about her confidence level. The tutors are phenomenal!!!! I am so grateful for the support of this organization.”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 5055 Richmond Rd, Bedford Heights OH 44146

    4.5 Superb 62 reviews

    “Store is very heavy on clothing side. Was looking for a few used pots or pans, The ones they had, I felt were overpriced as I could buy new for a few dollars more. Overall, the store is fairly organized and clean.”

  6. 32901 Vine Street, Willowick OH 44095

    4.5 Superb 53 reviews

    “This is the church I have searched for my whole life. This church has the heart of a SERVANT. Virtually everyone there works for the Lord Jesus. Working to provide food for those in need-free meals for all who want to come to them-teaching classes(which are really fun to go too!!)The prayer room for anyone who needs prayer-it is beautiful!) The fun little thrift shop-all the money goes to provide for the community meals and ministries!! come and visit us-we don't judge anyone. no matter what your past has been, we welcome you with open arms!”

  7. 715 Broadway Ave, Cleveland OH 44146

    5 Superb 10 reviews

    “Every time I go into this adorable shop I find enchanting as well as useful items ! Cookware, framed pictures, jewelry, blankets, and knickknacks for every holiday or collection. The staff are all volunteers, they’re kind, professional and very helpful, always.All $$$ goes directly to care for animals and fostering!! AMAZING”

  8. 11205 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland OH 44106

    4.4 Superb 7 reviews

    “Just stopped by for the first time after being in Cleveland for two years. It’s surprisingly amazing and the prices are shocking me too! People are nice and they’d help you find exactly what you want”

  9. 4639 Northfield Road, North Randall OH 44128

    4.1 Good 141 reviews

    “This little gem stays true to the thrifting culture. Prices are very reasonable for about 90% of the items within. One of the last stores around in northeast ohio that has not went into retail mode. A must stop if you are ever in the area. Clean, organized, and always a peaceful environment 😌 🙏”

  10. 34225 Vine Street, Eastlake OH 44095

    4.1 Good 123 reviews

    “My first time volunteering for Habitat for Humanity was at the 2025 Stars & Stripes 5k. The energy, dedication and team work of all the volunteers was amazing! I volunteered again for the 2025 Raise the Roof event. It was so much fun! I'm looking forward to future volunteer opportunities! If you're looking to become involved with a great organization, I highly recommend Habitat. A fun group with an honorable cause!”

  11. 2747 Fairmount Blvd, Cleveland Heights OH 44106

    3.9 Good 7 reviews

    “The staff were incredibly helpful, the clothing high-quality, and the prices very reasonable. Bought a brand new leather belt for my daughter for $8 and a NWT designer silk scarf for myself for $50.”

  12. 35101 Euclid Ave, Willoughby OH 44094

    4 Good 54 reviews

    “I can’t say enough good things about Ryan at the donation center My mom accidentally donated my sister’s beloved stuffer animal and he went through the back through bags to find it and help us An amazing person! Enough reason to continue supporting this place! A woman named Cecelia was also very helpful in guiding me to the right direction in the back!”

  13. 4601 Northfield Rd, North Randall OH 44128

    4 Good 89 reviews

    “This place is awesome on Northfield, everytime I go everyone is very friendly and they're like a small family and make you feel as though you're apart of their family too. The customer service is phenomenal and I and my friends visit often because this place is definitely a diamond in the rough. They might not have what you want this week but if you come next week it's on a shelf, you just never know what you'll find unless you stop by...”

  14. 4130 Erie St, Willoughby OH 44094

    3.8 Good 32 reviews

    “Staff was very nice and helpful! I brought in some items to the shop and they were very honest about the items that I brought! Great customer service! Very cute clothing and jewelry! Would definitely make the trip back and recommend this place to a friend!”

  15. 1798 Coventry Rd, Cleveland Heights OH 44118

    3.9 Good 173 reviews

    “I definitely had more success selling my merch in the past, 11 gently used items were sold, my offer was $41… Mind you I had brand new Vans & Versace Jean leggings, Lands End Flannel & Black Bart Cowboy Hat, & a few other misc items hoodie, pants & shirts… Plus side w a review you get 15% off one time only. I bought a $20 Race Car BooHoo MAN jacket & Adidas biker shorts $4.50..”

  16. 30604 Lakeshore Boulevard, Willowick OH 44095

    3.7 Good 170 reviews

    “This is a very decent thrift store I always find lots of good things here. If you check it out on Mondays you would definitely get a lot for your money because this is 50% off each and every Monday.”

  17. 6605 Mayfield Road, Mayfield Heights OH 44124

    3.4 Good 118 reviews

    “Stopped in because I was in the area and I was so impressed with the selection of clothes and shoes! The staff was super friendly and the prices were very reasonable. I normally shop at the American Cancer Society store in Chardon, but I will definitely be back here!”

  18. 30040 Lakeshore Boulevard, Willowick OH 44095

    3.3 Good 109 reviews

    “Decent pricing (MUCH better than Savers up the street)! Nice staff. A lot of their merchandise has scratches, rips, missing pieces, etc. But shop around and you'll find some great items.”

  19. 13908 A Cedar Rd, University Heights OH 44118

    2.9 Average 56 reviews

    “First off it's around back with Dollar Tree, Google parked me in front by the restaurant, it's a smaller store than my locations... Line wait 12mins...”

Advertisement

Thrift Stores in nearby cities