Sheetz of Mayfield Heights is a 24/7 convenience store that offers a variety of food, drinks, and other products. Known for its award-winning Made•To••Order® food and made-to-order Sheetz Bros. Coffeez® drinks, it provides a quick and easy one-stop shop experience. Customers appreciate the friendly staff and the store’s generally clean and well-maintained appearance. The store has seen improvements over time, though it can get overwhelmed during busy times, especially on Friday nights when school is in session. The food is consistently praised for being tasty and filling, with some mentioning specific favorites like the Shmuffin with fried chicken and French toast sticks. The store also offers a variety of packaged snacks, drinks, tobacco, and CBD products. The store's app adds convenience, allowing easy ordering and earning rewards for future purchases. Gas prices have fluctuated, with recent increases making them less competitive than nearby stations, which some customers find disappointing given the savings potential. Overall, Sheetz of Mayfield Heights is valued for its convenience, friendly service, and good food options, making it a popular spot for quick bites and fuel needs at any time of day.
This is Mayfield Heights’ only redeeming quality. Thanks for opening one here.
May 2026
MY FAVORITE GAS STATION. ALWAYS CLEAN, FRIENDLY, AND AIR PUMP WORKS
March 2026
This is my default stop for a quick meal on my way home from travel and have visited 2-4 times per month since the location opened and can't recall an unpleasant experience. It does all the Sheetz stuff as well as you'd expect, and the staff are always pretty friendly.
