New York Butcher Shoppe in Montgomery, OH, is a high-quality butcher shop and deli that offers a wide selection of premium meats, prepared meals, and gourmet grocery items. Known for its exceptional customer service, the staff is knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful, ensuring a welcoming experience for every customer. The shop features various cuts of meat, including A5 Wagyu and prime steaks, all of which are praised for their freshness, tenderness, and outstanding quality. Customers appreciate the reasonable prices for such high-grade products, making it a great value. In addition to fresh meats, the shop offers ready-made meals like meatball parm and other cooked sides, which are consistently delicious. Many visitors have found the prepared foods to be delightful and the meat to be on par or better than national retailers. The shop also provides catering services and an extensive wine selection, making it a convenient one-stop shop for dinners and events. With new products continually added and a commitment to traditional values blended with freshness, New York Butcher Shoppe has quickly become a favorite neighborhood destination. Customers frequently recommend it for quality meats, friendly service, and a pleasant shopping experience.
Rib Roast we ordered for Easter dinner was excellent. Pricey but great. We have reordered from there and each time the meat was delicious. Just ge prepared for the price.
February 2026
My husband and I are so glad we found this shop! Great quality food and even better customer service!
January 2026
I found this place a few months ago and everything I have tried has been delicious. From the meat, ready made meals to the desserts, it has all been amazing. Oh and the people who work there are very nice and friendly. I will keep going back!
