-
December 2023 by Shuvonna Waters
I’d been wanting to take my little girl here after our weekly library visit. ….Unfortunately, the experience was tainted. The lady in the front was nice and the location was very cute. I had anticipated returning to try other flavors. I purchased a single, raspberry cheesecake ice cream for my little one. She couldn’t eat it all, so mommy went in to finish the last few scoops. In my first scoop, I found a few random sprinkles.. we hadn’t ordered sprinkles.. Two scoops later, to my dismay, was a HAIR. Not my hair, nor my daughters hair. Needless to say, I left very disgusted… hoping my toddler had not ingested a stray hair that I did not notice.
-
August 2023 by Hawa Ndiath
Great service, great flavor ice cream always!!!
-
July 2023 by Jamie Fehring
Moose tracks kid scoop. Delicious and perfect size for $3.75!
-
July 2023 by Jamie Wengatz
Friendly staff, ice cream come out really soft (melted). It wasn’t my favorite.
-
July 2023 by Holly Meyer
Good quality, nice employees, short wait even though it was busy.
-
June 2023 by Cassandra R.
SO GOOD! First time visiting and I loved it. The store itself is very cute with great parking but also good accessibility from the rest of New Albany if you wanted to have a long walk with your ice cream! The employees were super friendly and helpful and I was grateful to get to sample a couple flavors because their menu is packed with options! I opted for the Buckeye flavor this time and it was delicious - creamy and the perfect peanut butter/chocolate balance without being too rich. the sugar cone was good too- nice and crispy with a good vanilla taste and not just from the cheap box you can find at the grocery (though I don't dislike those). I was only supposed to get one scoop but I definitely got a little extra. Excited to go back and try other flavors!
-
June 2023 by Myra Weisman
We love Johnson’s. My husband grew up with the Bexley shop and it’s the only ice cream he really enjoys. We love the hot fudge sundae. Their hot fudge is thick but not sticky sweet. We were in the New Albany area and had dinner. Opted for nearby Johnson’s rather than ordering dessert. We both ordered our faves - hot fudge sundae. What an incredible disappointment. On both there was a minuscule amount of hot fudge. Really stingy amount. They have upped the prices but decreased the amount of topping. In fact when I looked and saw the increased price another change was that you got 2 toppings - which they did not tell us. But since we only had one topping we should have gotten double the amount of topping not half the amount of one topping. Since this was our first time in the NA store we thought maybe it was different than the Bexley store. To find out - you will have to read my Johnson’s Bexley review.
-
June 2023 by Myra W.
Have always loved Johnson:s. Had never to the new Albany location, but had dinner nearby and instead of ordering a fancy dessert at the restaurant decided to go to Johnson's for our beloved hot fudge sundaes. It was such an incredible disappointment. We need a magnifying glass to find the hot fudge. They had raised the prices, but then when we looked up, we saw that it did say you got two topics. Well, our server did not tell us that we really hadn't read it. We just knew that we wanted a hug for Sunday as usual but we got half of one topping instead of double the amount since we only ordered one topic, we certainly paid for the two topping Sunday. We didn't get nuts or anything so maybe this is just the new Albany location and we would have to wait and see when we went back to our usual Bexley location. Defined out the verdict. You'll have to be the reviews from the Bexley store.
-
May 2023 by Karla Smith
Best ice cream I've ever had.Such a large variety of choices of ice cream and other treats.I'm kicking myself for not picking up some ice cream sandwiches and frozen bananas.Staff was very friendly and had smiling faces.I'll be back!
-
May 2023 by Diana P.
I have yet to visit a Johnson's Real Ice Cream that isn't worthy of 5 stars. Excellent flavor variety and more dairy free options than most places. I'm convinced their definition of one scoop equals two, which I'm very much a fan of! There were around 5 people working when I visited, so my wait time was non existent. There's a few tables inside and outside, so you have the option to enjoy both. A+ business!
-
April 2023 by Matthew Modrowski
Excellent variety of Ice Creams & super friendly staff!
-
March 2023 by Sarah B.
Cute little ice cream shop in New Albany with a large private parking lot around back. I tried the March special - mint cookies and cream. It was good, not great. The ice cream was more icy than I like it, wanted it to be more creamy. It did have great flavor, the perfect amount of mint. Got a good amount of ice cream for one scoop. Prices about the same as other ice cream shops around. I would eat it again (it's ice cream!), but wouldn't be my first pick.
-
February 2023 by tyann amos
This is a nice location with convenient parking. The staff is helpful. The ice cream is tasty. You should check it out!
-
December 2022 by Jahil Parker (Jahly Jolly)
LOVED IT. Ice cream is really difficult to mess up and they did not mess up lol. No complaints at all. Went around 7, quick service staff was nice. Place was clean. Grabbed a sundae. Normal icecream prices. Will gladly go back. Better options than GraetersParking: Parking Lot
-
November 2022 by Bruce Brothers
Cool little ice cream joint. Wasn't busy when we went, was there around 7pm. Many choices of flavors. You can get ice cream in cones, cups, sundaes, and shakes.
