-
March 2024 by Rob Wolfe
Got a turkey sub with bacon, amazing flavor, great price.
-
March 2024 by Stacy Morris
My husband called to order subs.the guy who answered was too busy talking to friends he wasn't even listening to what was being said.he was told what apartment and it went to a different apartment. We told the driver and he just laughed. So disappointed.
-
January 2024 by Dakota Barfield
Normally we have great service from this location however this time we called in for delivery and instead of being asked for our phone number as usual, we were asked our address. We have never had any issue having this location deliver to us, however this time we were told our location could not be delivered to. The person who answered the phone questioned the manager as well and the manager said delivery could not be done. We're not sure of the issue, but we would rather meet Creno's East at a closer location, than have to drive into New Concord. Food at this location is always great, however we are very displeased with this encounter.
-
January 2024 by DJ Bibart
Lo v e New Concord Crenos
-
January 2024 by Don Cauley
Had the xl calzone. Was huge about a 16in pizza that was folded full of cheese, sausage and pepperoni. Place is small 2 larger tables, 2 tall tops. Service was great, people were super r friendly. Lots of people picking up online orders.
-
December 2023 by Elizabeth Cicotte
Pizza was very good and hot! Salad was tasty and fresh! Staff was courteous, pleasant and friendly! Food was ready when we arrived to pick it up!I would order from here again when back in the area!
-
October 2023 by Joel Dickinson
Great food, friendly staff, small town charm.
-
October 2023 by randy bridwell
Menu prices are out of dated. This was brought to there attention and it has not been corrected. Very misleading. Not good business.Wheelchair accessibility: None has a step.
-
October 2023 by Zino
Ouch....just spent $30 on a frozen convenience store pizza ?
-
August 2023 by Melissa J Adams
Loveeeee the taco salad and
-
August 2023 by Lori Baker
Ordered chicken sub no lettuce xmayo!! Got lettuce n didn't get any xmayo!!
-
June 2023 by hhmuskie
I've been going to this Creno's Pizza shop since I was a student at Muskingum University back in 2009. I feel like the pizza shop (here in New Concord specifically) is on the decline. It used to be a fun place to hang out, but now the shop inside is always empty, even when classes are in session. It looks and feels dirty now. Tables have crumbs on them, and surfaces feel sticky. Staff is young, and is often goofing around when customers are there, including dancing and singing to music, which sometimes causes them to not hear or see that there is a customer standing at the register. They aren't the only pizza shop in town, which a lot of people prefer over Wally's, so I do feel like they need to work harder at keeping a good reputation in town to ensure they have a shop here in the coming future. I think Creno's leaves a lot to desire, and I wish they'd put a little more pride into their New Concord establishment in the best interest of their community.
-
June 2023 by Cory Andrews
Creno's is the place I buy from least! They have a lot of stuff but it's to costly. The world is costly enough.
-
May 2023 by Larrissa Freeland
They were understaffed but handled the restaurant like bosses they were incredibly amazing and kind I will be returning
-
May 2023 by Heath Alton
Best pizza I have ever had from a creno's
