Frosties Bait & Tackle is a long-standing store near Deer Creek State Park and beach, the closest one in the area. The store is much larger inside than it looks, and it is very well lit, neat, and clean. It offers a great variety of fishing tackle, bait, lures, and lines, plus some hunting things and camping equipment. The business also has a bit of everything else, including a fresh food restaurant and takeout, drinks, ice cream, and a gas station for cars and boats. Staff are always friendly, helpful, and provide awesome customer service. While some prices are a little steep, they are understandable given the lack of competitors nearby. It is a popular spot with plenty of parking.
The best and the only place for bait and ice cream.
May 2026
I stop by Frosties everytime I visit Deer Creek Dam to fish with my family. They offer alot of different things. Including but not limited to live baits, lures, weights, line, poles. As well as foods, snacks, drinks and the best ice cream in town. I only wish they had another restroom though 😆
April 2026
Love this place. Findlay employees. Good prices. You can eat here. Ice creams. Pretty much anything for a great fishing 🎣 day
