Shisler's Cheese House is a small, privately run cheese house and market established in 1958. It offers a wide variety of amazing cheeses, meats, and gourmet foods, including excellent aged extra sharp white cheddar and big eye Swiss. The shop also has tons of baked goods, bulk food items, bulk chocolates, sweets, and other Amish foods. The staff is extremely kind, friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable, providing great customer service. This favorite cheese house is one of the best Ohio cheese companies and is a great place to stop and check out.
Best cheese ever, their Ohio Swiss is amazing. There cube cheese to go was the perfect snacks and the candy & chocolates amazing. I can't wait to come back.
September 2026
Great products, but even more impressive customer service. My shipment was delayed coming to Florida, but the cheese was still delicious. That Amish Butter Cheese is amazing. We had a small issue, and they took care of it immediately. Will be ordering again (in the fall)…lol
August 2026
Always try to stop in when we are in the area, been going here for a long time
