-
October 2023 by markuss417
I've stayed here before and it was up to pretty much what you'd expect from a PIB Hotel. However, this time they assigned me to a room behind the pool in the separate building which is not part of the main building. This room type is *SIGNIFICANTLY* inferior and yet they charge the same price for this type of room. It is tiny and extremely outdated. A Motel 6 room would have been far superior to this room. Had I known I would have been assigned a room back there, I would absolutely not have booked it and would have stayed elsewhere. To make matters worse, we were assigned a room right along the back alley by the dumpsters so you're constantly greeted with the stench of dumpster juice (that leaks across the street) all day. Also, I know it was late season but they list their pool hours as opening at 10AM and both days they were not open until atleast Noon. I would have otherwise not left this review as it's PIB and we barely intend to be in the room for any meaningful time, but this place went out of it's way to be actively aggravating. My expectations were very low and I was shocked they still somehow managed to come up short!
-
September 2023 by Cody Harris
This was our second time at the commodore and we will be coming back! I suggest the pool view rooms. We had a slight issue with our room and Kelley was super accommodating and helped us out and gave us great reccomendations about things to do. Rooms are great rates and the best location on the island. Easy access to late night food. I will say if you’re looking for a quiet secluded place to stay, this might not be for you, but we come here for the fun atmosphere and this place puts you right in the middle of the action.
-
September 2023 by Scott Hanson
It's Put- In - Bay and you are right down town in the middle of everything. Room was really nice and clean! We like the fact that it was hard floors not carpet. Good price for down town Put- in- Bay!!! We will definitely be back again and stay at Commodore Resort Hotel! ??Nearby activities: Very nice lady at the counter ☺️
-
September 2023 by Yale Cunningham
Can't beat the central location and the Mist Pool is a happening scene. We had an absolute BLAST!!! ?
-
September 2023 by gobluegirl
I have stayed in almost all the hotels on the island. They are all about the same, I haven't found one that has stood out or been cleaner than others. Kelly & Sue were very friendly and helpful when booking and checking in. I saw others complain about cleanliness. Our room was clean and tidy. That is what matters the most to me. The bathroom could use some updating and wasn't great but again it was clean. We needed a place to crash after Bash in the Bay and this served the purpose. Overall not the best hotel, but not bad for PIB standards. It was clean but needs some updates!
-
September 2023 by Sydney Johnson
You’re only paying for the location—near a lot of bars and restaurants which were fun. We came for the bash on the bay concerts and would rent an air bnb next time.To start we were greeted by the rudest staff who originally said some of the rooms were remodeled over the phone then laughed at us upon arrival. The air conditioner was covered in black mold and the beds were completely caved in. The noise level at night was VERY loud and someone pulled the fire alarm in the middle of the night which resulted in everyone having to leave their rooms.This is definitely a promiscuous pool party/lady of the night hotel and should be booked for nothing more. If you’re a normal person looking to have a fun time with friends definitely rent a house!!
-
September 2023 by Sabrina Silvestri
GUESTS BEWARE for your credit card security with this place!! My family and I stayed at this place twice, once in 2021 and again in 2022. We made the reservations in 2021 with a credit card that had NEVER been used for anything else, around 6-7months after our stay, the card had mysterious charges on it from CVS that were fraud. Fast forward to 2022, we used a different credit card, that again had NEVER been used anywhere else, and again, charges showed up months later that were fraud. Not saying this was them, but coincidence, I don't think so. As for the rooms, they are dirty, smell of mold, but are cheap and close to the main strip which is nice. Will never stay here again though, financial security is where I draw the line.
-
September 2023 by Sarrah Magan
This is where drunk women about to get married go to "woo"And they are ridiculous rules. They want you to swim across the pool with your drinks rather than walk the five feet behind to get to the exact same spot.
-
September 2023 by rachel gilday (Rachel)
We had a great time! I wish the pool was bigger bc it stays
-
August 2023 by Patricia J
I haven’t been here in over a decade and tried to have an open mind about staying again. This place is disgusting. I have bug bites on my feet. There was no water pressure in the shower. I couldn’t wait to come home and feel clean again. Stood in 3 inches of water while showering. Not to mention there was almost no light in the room with the shower and toilet. Doors slammed all night long. I know it’s a party island but I didn’t sleep either night because of the doors slamming. Fire alarm went off for a half hour at 1am. The floors were FILTHY. Do yourself a favor and stay anywhere but here. The only redeeming qualities were the pizza window and the MTV Classics channel on the tiny tv, and the fridge. We left a day early. Charging what they charge with a minimum of nights, they have some audacity. Just gross.
-
August 2023 by Roger
I was very unhappy to have the smell of garbage hit me in the face hotel is off a alley.and to let everyone use a pool that paying guest are paying for was not cool.And when I booked I was miss informed that room had hot tub .Rooms: Rooms where ok up date alittleFood & drinks: The food and drinks on the island are very pricey
-
August 2023 by Issy Rinz
There is a screaming and banging going on at 1 am. Would not recommend for a family or couple that just wants to relax and go to bed . For 290 a night I would expect better. Will not be staying here again.
-
August 2023 by jeffreyt694
We had a service animal and within 5 mins of checking in we received a knock on the door and a very rude front office person informed us “this was not a pet friendly hotel—- even though they had their dogs behind the front desk !!! Very rude . I would have left if I could have got a refund. Bed poor. Refrigerator on high keep everything barely below room temperature. The AC very poor - on high working all night kept room at 82-84 warm degrees. We love Put -in - Bay been there many times - will go back but never will stay at the Commodore Resort again. Stay away !!!!!!
-
July 2023 by Stacey James
This was a non smoking room (room 247), but the bedspread had a cigarette burn in it. Don't go barefoot. the ceramic tile in bathroom was broke, the paint was pealing in several areas. The shower had hair in it from previous guest. Non of which I reported, because I was happy it did not have bed bugs and i can clean the rest.There was a fight in the middle of the the night, but there was no phone in the room to report it. I did not think to look in the binder on the other side of room for a phone number. The room did not have a remote, but when i requested on they did supply one.However, what irks me. is that i paid 199 a night plus fees. Yet they had it listed for 169 when we showed up. I did mention it. The staff states its like airline rates, they adjust in the attempt to fill the rooms. I understand completely, but many airline rate also will match the low rate you notice. Of course i only noticed because i was double checking the amenities. Amenities do NOT include a coffee pot in the room and no the Pool is not heated. They did tell me that I could risk waiting for a lower price, but the hotel may not have a vacancy. That alone would be worth the wait. I'd rather no vacancy than spend 199 at this hotel. Honestly, i believe 169 is high, but it is centrally located.so the good is: Has a pool bar (Don't even think about bringing a glass of water in the area though. You have to dump ALL beverages.). you can only buy from their pool bar.There is a Subway in the lobby.They offer free coffee in the morning.I did not have an issue with the staff, but that probably has everything to do with my vacation, cant bring me down attitude.location was great. put in bay itself is really cool.Rooms: if your room is on the side with the bar, they rock out late. if you are on the side of the pool bar, they shut down early, but maybe that is because its the beginning of the season.Nearby activities: plenty of stuff to do that is walkable.Walkability: Walk, run, skip jump, and stumble. you got this
-
July 2023 by elizabeth thompson
The hotel itself was very dirty the floors need to be scrubbed so bad. There's constant moisture in the room where you sit on the bed and feel like you sat in something damp when you stand up. My sisters room had a very stagnant smell. And My vitamins even got squishy because of the moisture in the room. The toilet seat isn't tight at all so when you sit on it it slides and the walls Definitely need a good painting and shower drains look black. The little area rug they had was a dollar tree special that needs replaced, I wish I could say something good but for the price they charge you'd think you'd get a clean room and the photos do not match what we got at all ?♀️
