-
June 2025 by Ethan Woessner
They are the best. Responds to emails late in the night and staff is super friendly. Also offers MSRP prices including Final Fantasy. My go to card shop!
-
May 2025 by Jon Jones
They sold me the newest Pokemon set at MSRP. Thank you guys so much
-
April 2025 by A A
Best prices in the city, friendly staff, and close to where I live
-
December 2024 by William Lash
Great staff, wide variety of products, and very knowledgeable
-
October 2024 by David Rodgers
Seems like more of a Magic the gathering place. I am not sure of the various events or other things that they have there, but their board game selection was really limited as of October 26th 2024. Seem like nice people. Lots of room to play. Tons of card selection for sure. I would recommend going there for Magic the gathering or other card based events.
-
September 2024 by Ben Smith
I played my first ever game of magic here. The staff was super helpful in getting me set up with a group of other players. The patrons were super helpful with teaching me the game. Good prices on cards and accessories. Overall great experience and I will definitely be back.
-
September 2024 by Chase Fisher
Reserved a table for our dnd night and had an absolute blast they are super accommodating!!! Thank you Gem City Games!
-
August 2024 by Stvr Fire
I only come here for cardboard and sleeves because they stopped carrying yugioh
-
July 2024 by Michael Charlton
Great place to play commander and a cool selection of stuff in the store!
-
May 2024 by Keith Vilseck Jr
Hark, fellow adventurers! Let me regale thee with tales of my sojourn to Gem City Games in Centerville, Ohio, a realm where magic thrives and camaraderie flourishes like the ancient forests of Lothlórien.
Firstly, the stewards of Gem City Games, with their keen minds and steadfast hearts, provided guidance akin to the wisdom of Gandalf himself. Their counsel was as welcome as the light of Eärendil in the darkest of times.
In the realm of Magic: The Gathering, Gem City Games reigns supreme like the majestic kings of Gondor. Their events, a tapestry woven with threads of excitement and strategy, beckon warriors from far and wide to test their mettle on the battlefield.
But beyond mere competition lies the true essence of Gem City Games – a fellowship akin to the Company of the Ring. Within its walls, players find not only opponents but allies, not only rivals but friends. Like the bonds forged in the fires of Mount Doom, the community of Gem City Games is unbreakable and enduring.
In conclusion, let it be known throughout Middle-earth that Gem City Games is a bastion of excellence, where staff, events, and community converge in harmony like the notes of an elven hymn. May its halls ever echo with the laughter and triumphs of heroes, and may its legacy endure for ages to come.
-
December 2023 by Brent White
Fantastic people, fair pricing. This is one of the only stores I give my business to, they're always nice, fast, and ready to answer any questions I have. Between this and one other store in the area, I only go to them. The hour drive is worth it.
-
November 2023 by XxOpiexX
Extreme mark up. Called and asked for a card that lists for $7 and they quoted me $11. These reviews that claim extreme mark ups are accurate. Will not be shopping here.
-
November 2023 by Denise Black Viscomi
Had good board game selection and people play games at this location. Check with them for days and times.
-
September 2023 by Louis Luedtke
Friendly place for my grandson to hang out.
-
September 2023 by Jeremy Perkins
I’ve only been in person once, so take this review with a hefty helping of salt. The time I went in was very pleasant. The person working the desk (I think the owner?), was very personable and a pretty cool guy. I could tell he enjoyed his job and was following MTG pretty closely as one would expect. They had everything I’d asked for over the phone the day before set away and the prices were what I expected. He even offered to trade in one of my cards for a different printing that I preferred! We’re this my only experience it would be a 5/5 just because of how chill the atmosphere was, how helpful the owner was, and the prices.Unfortunately I did have a bad experience with one employee who I won’t name or describe. I asked whether or not the store sold some specific tokens I was looking for, and rather than attempt to answer the question or take my name/# and perhaps call me back after they checked, the person simply said that they had too many tokens to check and left it at that. I thought it was strange that rather than check (not right away mind you, that would’ve been fine, I understand it’s a lot), the employee simply said they couldn’t know and couldn’t check because they were overstocked on token inventory. I hate to judge a person just by a single phone call but I’ve heard poor things about them before and they seemed upset about my question which I also thought was weird given the fact that working at a hobby store would be a dream come true for me.Otherwise this place is pretty great and I wouldn’t let me bad experience dissuade you from at least coming and looking. I still plan on shopping here when I’m in the area despite my experience if that tells you anything at all.
