Casey's in Xenia is known for its excellent pizza delivery and pickup, featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The store is always clean, well-stocked, and offers a variety of food, drinks, and household essentials. Customers report a good experience with very nice and helpful staff. Many appreciate that it is the only local place selling E85 flex fuel. While some note prices may be a little more, the consistent feedback is that the food is great, excellent, and of way better quality than competitors.
Stopped in because I needed gas, never been to a Casey's before. They had E 85 and E 15 besides the regular gas blends. I was impressed.
September 2026
There are always a ton of fresh food options and the store is always super clean and organized. They have something for just about any mood you’re in. 10/10 if I could
August 2026
Friendly! Ordered pizza in the app for pickup to take advantage of the deals. Definitely recommend. Pizza was great!
