Casey's in Xenia is known for its excellent pizza delivery and pickup, featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The store is always clean, well-stocked, and offers a variety of food, drinks, and household essentials. Customers report a good experience with very nice and helpful staff. Many appreciate that it is the only local place selling E85 flex fuel. While some note prices may be a little more, the consistent feedback is that the food is great, excellent, and of way better quality than competitors.
Allways have what I need, great staff and the only gas station around with e85 gas
May 2026
All around great place, amazing pizza 🍕
May 2026
Their breakfast pizza is fantastic but they do not cater to the morning work rush. If you need a quick bite in the morning, go somewhere else. You will wait in a very slow line a minimum 10 minutes. It's a fact for both Fairborn and Xenia locations as I travel this route weekly.
