Citgo is a popular ice cream shop known for its delicious, homemade ice cream made fresh daily on site. Customers often praise the variety of flavors available, with around thirty options that include favorites like Chocolate Pecan, Graham Central Station, and Red Skies at Night. The ice cream is typically loaded with ingredients such as chocolate chunks and nuts, offering a rich and satisfying experience. Portions are generous, and the shop offers a convenient 4-scoop sampler for $5.50, making it easier to try multiple flavors. Many visitors appreciate that the shop stays open late, allowing for a sweet treat after dinner or in colder months, when some still brave the cold to enjoy the ice cream. Some reviews mention minor issues such as hairs in the ice cream, but overall, customers highly recommend Citgo for its tasty products and friendly service. Known for its high quality and variety, Citgo has become a favorite in the Mahoning Valley and has expanded to other states, attracting both locals and visitors who enjoy their ice cream as much as the reviewers do.
Who doesn't love some delicious home made ice cream?!We stopped by on the way home from dinner to satiate our sweet tooth. I am a s***** for s'mores ice cream and my partner loves a good praline pecan.We enjoyed our choice and appreciate how they had a lot of toppings folded in. Definitely recommend!
June 2023
Ice cream was great, the two hairs in it weren't as great.I loved that they have a 4 scoop sampler for $5.50... makes the decision a lot easier when you don't have to choose just one.I also love that they stay open late.Blueberry Cobbler was awesome. Solid balance of ice cream to fruit swirl.
February 2023
Their ice cream is the best! It's so good that I saw a customer at the window during a raging snowstorm.
