Casey’s in Broken Arrow, OK, is known for its delicious pizza, made with scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The location offers pizza delivery and pickup, along with a selection of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. Many customers enjoy the pizza but recommend double-checking orders to ensure accuracy. The service is highlighted as friendly and helpful, with one employee receiving special praise for exceptional customer service. While the pizza is generally well-received, there have been occasional delays in orders. Some customers have noted issues with gas pump payment systems and communication regarding fuel availability. However, the store has a new manager and team members working to improve operations. The parking is ample, and the environment is kid-friendly, making it a convenient stop for families. Overall, Casey’s aims to provide quality food and service, making it a popular choice for both dining in and taking out.
The older blonde cashier that was there today was not friendly. She wasn't necessarily rude but I could tell that I was inconveniencing her by asking for help. I was not there for food. Only gas and the store.
August 2026
Love Casey's! Was so glad when they came here. Store is clean, pleasant staff, great pizza and other foods. Lots of drink flavors and options. Enough gas pumps that I don't have to wait in line.
March 2026
The gas here is always higher then most. They have hot food thats okay. Big selections of drinks and alcohol. Google shows this as a restaurant and it is not.
