Casey's is known for its delicious pizza, which comes at a decent price and offers plenty of vegetarian toppings. Customers appreciate the friendly staff, with one reviewer noting the kindness of an employee who delivered pizzas to a car. The store is clean and convenient, although some mention that food prices can be a bit high and the taste sometimes resembles generic frozen options. Casey's is family-friendly, often busy with kids, and provides adequate parking, including handicap accessibility. However, it's important to note that the Jay store does not open at 4 AM, and their gas pumps are not available 24 hours.
Great staff is always fast just the young ones that are slow and don't seem to want to be there or attitude
September 2026
Our local home town caseys, great store, good food and love the workers!
July 2026
It was in jay so smaller town but by 3 they were already discussing packing up all their food and they didn’t have much out to begin with. I was surprised by the prices of their Casey’s brand items
