-
November 2025 by Crystal Barwick
My husband went to buy Pizza. He told the lady needed a Sausage Pizza. The lady misunderstood and said reach in the case and get it yourself. He told her he needed whole pizza. He said she was very rude even more after that. The cashier when I went to check was very she made feel like I bothering because I wanted to pay our pizza and 3 waters. We were Kingfisher visiting. We will never come to this store ever again. Worst service ever!!!
-
November 2025 by Cortezshane99
Love thier food selection, pizza is great; wish they were 24 hrs
-
November 2025 by Nathanael De Luis
5 stars!!!! Thanks to Jessica and the crew in Kingfisher, Oklahoma for their very amiable and courteous employees. Store was clean and running smoothly! Friendly atmosphere, clean restrooms and very professional management. Y'all are amazing and absolutely rock!!!
-
October 2025 by David Gibbs (Dave)
I love the breakfast pizza! Plus you can get fuel and use the restroom and buy a little groceries & what have you for the road? And if you have Casey's rewards, you get a discount on your fuel at the pump every time! What's not to love at Casey's?
-
September 2025 by Todd Hewitt
Casey's is a wonderful place to go staff is always nice friendly and very helpful. Foods always fresh and hot very clean it would highly recommend this place.
-
June 2025 by Vickie Parker
Good service inside the gas pumps are frequently unavailable not all at once.
-
March 2025 by Brandi N
There over the phone etiquette is crap.
-
November 2024 by Greg Bender
Saturday evening we ordered a large pizza, they have had the best in Kingfisher, but, this was the third time the quality was subpar, September 8, ordered supreme pizza, checked before we left location, it was cheese, jalapeño, and a few mushrooms, wrong, made us one correctly, checked it, was not completely baked, got home, 8 blocks away, checked with a temp gun, 95 degrees, we baked in our oven to finish, was good. Pizza Hut is terrible. Gave Casey’s another shot, nope under cooked, I guess it is Papa John now. Probably won’t give them a fourth chance, especially since employees did not offer coupon for poor quality product.,
-
November 2023 by Monica Ghoul
Nice, clean and welcoming!?
I was actually pretty impressed as a first time customer, the store was really well put together and it looked like it was well maintained also.
Had a big selection of items and lots of travel size things incase of forgetting something while traveling!
The pizza and food selection also looked super yummy, so we might have to stop and get a pizza sometime!?
-
November 2023 by Barbara Lewis
Great quick stop..lots of coffee and fountain drinks, fairly decent prices friendly clerks...always
-
October 2023 by Rodger Black
Tried using Casey’s reward to cash in my points for being a loyal Casey’s customer and spending my money here. App doesn’t give clear instructions on how to use or if redeemed for fuel which is based on getting 20 gals of gas do you get remaining points back if not getting the full 20 gals today, asked store employee, which had no idea which is fine but then she proceeded to treat me like I was rude and an inconvenience for trying to figure out how to redeem my points while at the register where I was trying to get help, why have the points at all and why are staff not trained to help customers with the app? Finally figured out the points but she then wanted to continue with checking out everyone else in the store and not return to help me.
-
June 2023 by Kathy Altizer
Is always quick for a convenient store. Its pizzas are great. Biscuit & Gravy pizza is surprisingly wonderful. Gas prices are reasonable for small town.
-
June 2023 by Oremus Press Newspaper
Quality should remain consistent / Cut the WasteEveryone always, of course, comments on Casey's famous pizza. It WAS excellent back when the location opened in Kingfisher, OK. But, that was when the chain's overseers were on-site to make sure things stayed up to par. Since then, I have routinely found pizza in the rotating warmer that should have been pulled over an hour prior. It was sitting there looking dried out and less-than-appetizing. Nevertheless, after observing other customers look the pizza over and turn away for the same reason, I made an offer to buy them at half-price since they were old. I was told "I don't think we can do that." So...the slices obviously went COMPLETELY unsold and were tossed. We have no problem with shopping at "salvage grocery stores," so this just feels like a waste all around. Food that is not in its prime, but still edible is wasted, and the store loses $$ because it doesn't have a policy to sell it at a discount.Also, back when it opened, this location offered a variety of pizza choices on their turn-table. Now, it's just pepperoni, beef, or sausage, and not nearly as good as they used to be.As for fuel, the pumps are usually working and the price is decent.
-
May 2023 by John Fagan
It's a convenience store, clean restroom ?
-
May 2023 by Olga Faison
Extremely rude
