-
January 2026 by Mike Miller
If i could go lower I would. Second time I ordered from this store and both times my pizza was dry hardly any sauce I asked for extra and it is as dry as the dessert no more Casey's
-
January 2026 by Maggie James
My wife fell in the women's restroom bc of Febreze air freshener made it very slippery the wet floor sign was behind the door we was told well our boss wants it in there ! Didn't even care to give us a mangers number just well they want it in there ! Now my wife is super sore and we are on a road trip
-
December 2025 by Kyle Collins
👍👍
-
July 2025 by Chad Thompson
Come on cases you can do way better than this This story is busy there's a huge space beside the store for this truck to park he could park easily and not have to interfere with this much of the public trying to go about their business This is unprofessional and rude I was a delivery driver for years and years and years and I never ever parked my truck in front of a convenience store like this to block customers This is outrageous I'm done with you Casey's I'm not coming back to the store ever until you do better The manager should never allow this to happen This is just so that worker could be lazy! I work for Indian Nation for years and years and years and we would never been allowed to park our truck like that!
-
April 2025 by Marie
Bathroom filthy, counters filthy and workers are unpleasant.
-
March 2025 by Tara McNelly
** Ok Casey's, what about the clerk refused to give me my change on 2 different transactions? That's theft. When my niece spoke up about it an agressive argument ensued.
No slight apology and dismissal will grant Casey's another opportunity to steal and defend that behavior!!
I was basically stolen from. The store has a handwritten note taped to the doors cash only while updating. Inconvenient. The store was very dirty & trashy. Both purchases I made I was short-changed bc the cashier had no loose change. We were at the store for more than 20 mins bc we ordered a pizza. The cashiers apathetic dismissive response & attitude was beyond unsettling. He made no effort to apologize or do anything to give me the rest of my money. Very poor customer service.
-
February 2025 by Luna
Poor customer service guy acted like he couldn't careless.. it was a tall guy with dreads. Some people smh.. (Wish the other people was there ruin my night and my kids.)
-
August 2024 by Greg Robinson
When are you guys going to realize that your water faucet at your air pump has been dumping water all over the parking lot for at least a month now? I mean seriously!? The ditch by the road is flooded, and it hasn't rained in like 2 or 3 weeks..lol I can't imagine what that water bill is going to be!
-
August 2024 by Brock Owensby
Horrible staff. Can’t even make a pizza on time let alone a decent pizza
-
August 2024 by Red Coleman
July 28/24 8:00PM. Bathroom was filthy. Store Floors filthy. Stock low. No signs on the gas pumps saying that every transaction had to be done inside but when our pump showed an error we went inside and were told. Desk clerk so stoned he could only mumble sleepily. A homeless man was bathing in the air and water kiosk. We love Casey's and have been to 76 E Peak Blvd, Muskogee many times in the past. We were shocked at how it has deteriorated. From looking at other reviews in recent months, this is not a new problem. First time we've seen only 3 vehicles there. Used to be a busy place.
-
March 2024 by Scotty Ryland
Bathrooms were absolutely disgusting, like embarrassingly nasty... hardly anything stocked. Definitely not enough employees for the foot traffic. Worst Casey's experience ever.... Definitely one to avoid in the future.
-
January 2024 by Callie Connolly
Amazing place to air up a tire and balance. I prepaid on pump three today and it wouldn’t work so I switched to pump 8 which had an error code. I left without gas. Also noticed they were out of premium.
-
December 2023 by Lisa Ledbetter
I cannot stand this store, why does it take sooooooo long to complete one transaction, the employees are slow with zero focus or any sense of urgency. This is with all casey stores. Im expecting a auto reply saying you're not firing on all cylinders ?. It is obvious you are not concerned about continuous improvement. Also, why when I have too much to carry, the person behind the register waits for the long transaction process to finish, then asks if I need a sack, because they are hoping they don't have to do that ?. So frustrating, the team members are not trained to be efficient.
-
December 2023 by Tyler Hediger
I love the breakfast pizza here is amazing a little expensive but what isn't anymore
-
September 2023 by Lori Hamilton
Fountain out of 32 oz cups and coke. Nicole had a cow because she had to restock them when the store was busy. I was in line and had to get out to get a cup/drink and then waited for several more people then she gave the guy behind me a free drink and charged me, pathetic. The women's bathroom smelled horrible. Elderly lady in the kitchen hollered to Nicole how she hated making pizzas with a store full of customers and it was the most unwelcoming, unpleasant Casey's I have ever been in. I even offered to put the cups in the dispenser. Nicole never said a word just acted ticked off with every transaction. Kurstin came and covered the counter for a moment and was pleasant.
