Casey's in Muskogee, OK, located at 4001 W Okmulgee St, offers a delightful experience with its made-from-scratch pizza, fresh toppings, and real mozzarella cheese. The business not only provides pizza delivery and pickup but also features appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and groceries, making it a convenient stop for customers. Many reviews highlight the friendly staff, with one customer sharing a positive late-night experience where a team member opened the store despite technical issues. Another reviewer praised their amazing breakfast sandwich and the welcoming service, expressing a desire to return. The store has transformed from a previously run-down gas station to a vibrant general store with an expanded area and a new pizza section. Customers appreciate the helpfulness of staff, like one employee who guided a customer on the rewards app. However, there was feedback regarding the demeanor of one overnight staff member, suggesting a need for improved friendliness. Overall, Casey's is recognized for its quality food and supportive staff, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all customers.
