Peter Pan Market & Deli is a cozy community corner store and deli located at the top of the hill. It offers a variety of gourmet sandwiches, with popular choices like the Bangarang and Youngs Bay of Pigs, known for their fresh ingredients and delicious flavors. The deli features indoor and outdoor seating, creating a cool and inviting atmosphere. In addition to sandwiches, it has a market with snacks, drinks, and odds and ends, making it a convenient stop for essentials. Customers appreciate the quality and taste of the food, especially the well-grilled sourdough bread and flavorful spreads. The potato salad is also a favorite. The store offers draft beer, craft soda, and wine by the glass, enhancing the community feel. While some find the sandwiches a bit pricey, many consider it a special treat and a go-to spot for good food and friendly service. Overall, Peter Pan Market & Deli is a charming place with a farmhouse feel, serving tasty food and fostering a warm, welcoming environment.
Great neighborhood deli and coffee shop! Friendly service and good food and coffee is good too!
January 2025
Came for the carrot cake based on reviews and was fairly underwhelmed. The copious frosting was great as I love frosting but the cake lacked any real flavor. The macaroon on the other hand was amazing! I'll be back for macaroons and to try other items for sure.
December 2024
Super cute little store. Indoor and outdoor seating. Cool atmosphere. I ordered the Dos Santos sandwich. Hands down one of the best deli sandwiches I’ve ever had! The flavors were amazing! The cheese pull was shocking and the sour dough was perfectly grilled! 10/10 would order it again!
