-
May 2024 by Brooke Morrow
This store is truly a gem! The owner, and all the folks that work here are knowledgeable, authentic, kind, and very helpful. My husband purchased my 1910 engagement ring, and 1920s wedding band here in 2010. Since then, I have continued to depend on them for my antique jewelry desires and repairs. And they have always taken extremely good care of me, and my treasured pieces.
-
April 2024 by Andrew Hart
Its a really nice store. Everyone is nice and helpful.
-
March 2024 by David Russ
This is not simply a jewelry store, but a deep repository of knowledge and love for art, vintage pieces, stones, and especially engagement rings. They have most helpful staff, always patient and interested only in helping me find the right piece for my wife. I can't say enough good things about this amazing store.
-
January 2024 by judith p.
Their antique jewelry is beautiful and unique! I have collected antique jewelry for my entire adult life. Their shop is such a find. They have museum quality collectible pieces. They are lovely people to work with.
-
January 2024 by Adam Jelsing
Best jewelry shop in town!
-
January 2024 by Logan Ashley
My fiancé got my engagement ring from here and I couldn’t be happier ✨ cutest store with friendly staff who have a passion for their beautiful jewelry
-
January 2024 by pious techpriest
Bought a vintage wedding ring here and we absolutely love it. Great collection. Parking is a little tricky, as with all places in that area (can't avoid that)
-
January 2024 by Mickey Deagle
Paula helped me pick out my wife's engagement ring eight years ago. She and her staff have experience, knowledge, and warmth second to none. They have made a lifetime customer out of me, and a very happy woman of my partner.
-
November 2023 by crystal mck
Bought a vintage band online, it is so adorable and in excellent condition, would shop again!
-
September 2023 by Jennifer Courchaine
The curation at Gem Set Love is fantastic. Gorgeous one of a kind pieces!
-
April 2023 by ScrapperGrrl
What a wonderful experience we've had with Gem Set Love! 22 yrs ago, my husband proposed with another estate engagement ring that I loved to pieces over the years...unfortunately quite literally. For the past several years we've weighed repair vs re-design vs purchasing new (to us). Over the past couple of years I've been making lists of favorite styles and eras looking for the one I would love most. At last I found Gem Set Love practically in our backyard. Their collection of rings and other jewelry is unique and well-curated. On both of our visits they answered our questions kindly and thoughtfully, and today we were back to bring home THE RING! It's so perfect for me it didn't even need to be sized. :) I can't stop gazing at it with a grin. This year was our 20th wedding anniversary. I look forward to enjoying the glow of this almost 100 year old beauty on my finger for many years to come and feel quite certain this was just the first of many visits to Gem Set Love. Highly recommend!
-
March 2023 by Jessica A.
My partner and I got the most beautiful rings. Their selection is incredible. We were walk ins on a Saturday afternoon and they completely accommodated us. We felt no pressure during the whole process and are still in love with them a month later!
-
December 2022 by Madison Reed
This shop has it all - an excellent selection of vintage jewels, knowledgeable staff, and friendly customer service!My partner and I stopped in here to look at their engagement rings and I fell in love with an engagement ring/wedding band set.A few weeks later, my partner proposed with that set. It needed to be resized, and gem set love was able to resize both rings in only 3 days. Wow, I’m so thrilled to wear and admire this vintage beauty everyday! As someone who loves all things vintage and values sustainability, this store and my ring checks all my boxes!
-
October 2022 by B K.
Really appreciate GSL! They made making the purchase easy and the ring itself is better than advertised. Also, I reached out much later (over a year) to get more details on the ring, and they happily provided information for me. Thanks GSL!
-
September 2021 by Tina Lips
Paula is a great jeweler. I inherited some pieces that weren’t my style and I brought them to her at Gem Set Love and got back 3 pieces I love. I wear them everyday. I had no clue how to proceed and she patiently listened to my meanderings about simplistic and classic styles and came up with 3 new settings that were perfect. I love perusing their vintage styles as well and will invest in some more pieces in the near future!
