-
March 2024 by Lorie Jacob
Meatball sandwich was great. Pizza was definitely not NY style.
-
March 2024 by Luke
Great food and friendly staff. My favorite is the Chicago beef sandwich.
-
March 2024 by B R
All very good. I'll be back!Parking: Few parking spaces but was worth going there. I'll go again for lunch and go to try dinner. This was my first time going there.
-
March 2024 by Autumn Hambas
The food was amazing. The service was prompt. We asked our server between our two choices which one she thought was best she answered honestly I would say this place wasn't a five stars⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
-
March 2024 by Tim Bam (Τιμόθεος)
It’s like walking into some mom and pop corner deli in Jersey. Love their meatball and chicago beef subs. The bread is perfect, however i wish they would serve the beef sub with a side of au jus and giardiniera.
-
February 2024 by Doug Nelson
Pepperoni pizza and best hot pastrami sandwich this side of New York!
-
February 2024 by Zach Kaiser (Zeke)
Got the chicken Geraldi and it was divine! Definitely going back!!!
-
February 2024 by Grayson Hogard
Really good sandwiches! You will not be disappointed.
-
February 2024 by alfonso arteaga
I used to work at one of the Geraldis in Arkansas and it was pretty spot on to what I know. Worth the 3 hr drive. I ordered the Italian sausage and they cut it into medallions instead of lengthwise. Other than that, flavor match is what I remember. Very good. I’ll need to come back and get the chicken parm sandwich and the Chicago beef.
-
February 2024 by Teea Schilder
It's my first time here and I ordered the spaghetti without meatballs and it came with a pile of garlic bread! However I didn't know that and ordered some, so I ended up with an abundance of garlic bread. I thought the food was really good! And a side bonus, is they didn't mind us eating and playing a board game ❤️ definitely coming back ☺️
-
February 2024 by Jacqueline Carrington
We ordered 3 two foot sandwiches each on a board for our Super Bowl party. Automatic gratuity was added even though the total was under $150. Then when we came to pick them up they handed them to us in trays instead of on the boards we had ordered and paid for. When this was pointed out, they handed us the boards separately. If you are going to take automatic gratuity of 18% on top of a service charge, you should at least get the order correct. Sandwiches tasted great and were a big hit.
-
February 2024 by Natalie Peran Teigen
The meatball sandwich, oh my goodness it is divine. Hubs and I split a full sando (only $2 more than the half), and it is perfect. We've been loyal Giraldi's patrons since the late 90s, and the deliciousness has not changed in all that time.
-
February 2024 by Aaron Simler
Ordered the Italian beef and received the wrong sandwich. It was a beef and sausage combo. My mother ate a third of it before stopping because it had tasted very “off”. She became very ill with food poisoning not long after and was sick for three days. Never again.
-
February 2024 by Carl Boehm
This place is the best. Amazing sandwiches, pizza, and the staff is kind.
-
February 2024 by Noemi Barajas
my coworkers recommended this shop and i am now completely obsessed with the pizza bread. the portions are worth the prices! i recommend this place for pizza and sandwich lovers.