-
February 2024 by Alice
The owner, Buddy Kellar, was great! Very professional. Reviewed the coins we had and gave us an extremely good offer. We will use his business in the future.
-
February 2024 by dex
The man who waited on us named Buddy did an amazing job and gave us more than a fair price. Very trust worthy and honest gentlemen!
-
February 2024 by P C
One of the worst buying experiences that I’ve had at a coin store in over a decade. This store is not interested in selling any coins. Extremely rude owner and staff was not interested in taking any coins out to look at. Wasn’t greeted and had to specifically ask the staff in order to get their attention to even show interest as a customer. I can’t speak on if I were to sell to the store but if their offers are as bad as their customer service, I would 100% recommend going elsewhere
-
January 2024 by P C.
Worst service ever seen at a shop. Owner and staff had no interest in showing any coins to me. Seemed "too busy" to deal with anyone other than their local customers when I travel the country to buy coins at shops.
-
November 2023 by Lisa A
Good experience today selling some coins. The owner, Buddy, is very fair, knowledgeable and helpful. I will recommend Buddy at Keystone Rare Coins to everyone.
-
October 2023 by Dorothy L.
Didn't get the price I supposed to get. Never gotten a itemized receipt. Best to know the value of your merchandises. Do not bring too many items at one time because you will be confused. I feel cheated. Not happy with the result.
-
September 2023 by Monica Lewellis
Today I had a very good experience selling a coin collection. The owner was very knowledgeable and courteous. I was very satisfied with the outcome. I highly recommend Keystone Rare Coins.
-
June 2023 by Liz Hartranft
Gave me a very fair price for the coins I brought in to the shop. Friendly staff
-
April 2023 by Queen Mary
Bought from Keystone Coin and can highly recommend. Owner is extremely knowledgeable, and generous with good advice even when it doesn't profit him. Prices are more than fair.
-
April 2023 by M S
Not really a coin store at all. They aren't interested in selling anything, not good for hobbyists and collectors. Exists solely to buy your collection for too cheap to charge too much online.
-
February 2023 by Dan K
Had a good experience today selling a coin collection. I was given a fair price for everything. He explained what the items were worth and made sure the the price was agreeable to me. If you need an honest appraisal or wish to sell items this is the place. Well worth the visit today.
-
February 2023 by Richard Knauss
I received quotes from Buddy and found them to be extremely competitive. Unlike some other shops I visited, I felt I was being treated fairly. If you are only going to one shop to sell your coins do yourself a favor and make it this one.
-
November 2022 by Joel Dries
The owner, Buddy, was extremely knowledgable. His offer was more then fair, was actually higher then two other offers that i declined. I would definately go here again, and plan on it. Highly recommended.
-
June 2022 by samantha shields
Went in today to sell some old coins got a good price he was also very knowledgeable will definitely be going back.
-
March 2022 by pat johnson
My sister and I had several different types of coins that we wanted to cash in. Buddy was so very helpful, knowledgeable, and professional, we had a relaxed exchange and left satisfied. I would highly recommend Keystone.
