-
March 2024 by david moore
It's a little dated but the food is outstanding!
-
March 2024 by E Stirr
Always delicious! After not visiting this treasure for a few years I was in the neighborhood and couldn’t pass up the opportunity. Colarusso’s did not disappoint. The pizza with the special cheese was as good as always, the vodka shrimp pasta special was just that, so special it was insanely delicious! Service efficient and personalized. thank you for not changing what I have missed!!! Until next time!!!!
-
March 2024 by Paul R Schneider
Pizza was excellent
-
March 2024 by Sidney Booth
Great pizza, white to die for, creamy, delicious, hot and
-
March 2024 by Justine S.
Had my baby shower here was excellent we had chicken marsala, white wine, chicken, meatballs, sausage and peppers, and tomato garlic pizza. The tomato garlic pizza is unlike any other in this area. I am more of a Sicilian New York type of pizza person. I enjoy Classic New York pizza so in this area it is mainly old Forge but this pizza is flavored so well it makes you forget that it is old Forge pizza. The tomatoes are cut enough so that you can take a bite of the pizza and the tomato doesn't fall off the pizza Has also flavored very well. We had an excellent service. They even went out of their way to bring their own decorations. The regular pizza is also good. I think they might put very small minced onions in the sauce which adds to it being almost like a fried pizza even though it's still old forage it's almost like hybrid. I haven't tried any other other pizzas besides the regular and the tomato, but you can't go wrong with either one of them.
-
March 2024 by Mark Fagotti
I haven't had their wings in quite a while so i ordered some for super bowl Sunday. They were fantastic! Probably the best I've ever had. A couple weeks later I got them again and they were the WORST WINGS I EVER HAD. Overcooked, dry, chewy and very little sauce. Must have had a better cook on the day of the super bowl.
-
February 2024 by Norms Orders
Great food excellent
-
February 2024 by Tony Grabosky
Pizza good.
-
February 2024 by Sarah soeb
Love the tomato pizza that my fav ?
-
January 2024 by Dennis Puhalla
Best Fresh Tomato Pizza
-
December 2023 by Chris W.
"Why fix something that's not broken". This had always been my absolute favorite old forge style pizza place. We moved to AZ but every time we come back to visit we head here. It's been a few years so once we got in town I couldn't wait to go. Family warned me they changed but I didn't believe it. Boy, I was wrong. The sauce is way too sweet and the quintessential old forge cheese blend is not even close. Sadly, I will no longer be saying it's my favorite ?
-
December 2023 by James C.
The double stuffed white pizza is fantastic! The tray of red is very good, too! Lastly, the meatball and sausage platter is great.
-
December 2023 by Dean K.
Best red in the area! Best pizza in Old Forge area and in the valley! People are great and the atmosphere is awesome.
-
November 2023 by Tom Kaplavka
It's all about the sauce. Barmaid was charming & attentive.
-
October 2023 by Angelo Bruno
Food came fast. Kids gave it a THUMBS UP!Kid-friendliness: Kids meal was cooked well and fresh
