Nesthaminy Stamps and Coins is a premier collectibles shop with over 35 years of industry experience. Offering a vast array of top-quality products and services, the store caters to the needs of avid collectors. Customers can enjoy weekly card tournaments, sell their gold and precious metals for top dollar, and explore the extensive selection of stamps, cards, and card games.
The staff is praised for their exceptional customer service, providing helpful information and fair offers when evaluating customers' collections. The owner, known for his kindness and reasonableness, often goes the extra mile, such as waiving sales tax. While the selection may be more suitable for those with diverse collections, the store is highly regarded by loyal customers who have spent thousands of dollars there.
Despite a few negative reviews, the majority of customers express satisfaction with the store's organization, pricing, and overall experience. Nesthaminy Stamps and Coins is a must-visit destination for collectors seeking a reliable and enjoyable shopping experience.
We stopped by looking for a few specific items, and while they didn't have everything we hoped for, the prices were surprisingly reasonable. We ended up finding some good deals on what they did have in stock.
July 2026
Went in a few times for their yugioh collection they have a wide variety of singles at a very good price. They did low ball me on a card I was trying to sell and luckily decided to just sell it myself on ebay. Over all not a terrible place but I wouldn't try to sell to them unless desperate for on the spot cash
May 2025
I stopped in a few weeks ago for some MTG cards and had a great experience. The owner was nice and friendly. The booster packs were reasonably priced and there were tons of cheap singles to look through. I had a good experience and am looking forward to going back
