-
March 2024 by Judi pond
Did take out/Delivery why I gave atmosphere a 3 but service is great food was awesome I haven't ordered much of my ordinary yet so far but definitely going to be trying new things soon!Kid-friendliness: Both family friendly/Adult friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes u can get in with a wheelchair and I'm sure they'd help you with the front door as well.
-
March 2024 by Damian Roberts
Ordered pickup, the crew was great! Heard them double checking to make sure entire order was together before bringing it out, much appreciated! Food was great, best I’ve had in the area!
-
February 2024 by daniel fisher
Pretty good food, steak hoagie was excellent. Pricey but good. $17 sandwich with drink.
-
February 2024 by Meghan Kibe
We have never had a bad hoagie here. We ordered pizza for the first time for the family with their Valentine’s Day heart pizza. And even with delivery it came hot. Definitely one of the best pizza places in Elizabeth.
-
February 2024 by Deanna Forkey
Ordered food at 8pm on a Sunday. While I waited a bit for delivery, it was still pretty quick given the time and where we live! The food was amazing. And the driver was very nice and professional! I can’t wait to order again!The buffalo chicken fries are absolutely amazing!
-
January 2024 by Stephanie Singleton
Food isn't bad, it's actually pretty good. But prices for chicken are misleading. Ordered a dozen "whole " split wings. They didn't have actual full in tact wings so, the split wings are the closest to it. It however was not a dozen whole split wings. It was 6 full wings that were cut into 6 drums and 6 flats. Should have been the actual dozen of whole wings, 12 flats and 12 drums. Basically, 12 whole wings cut into pieces. Not 6 wings split into 12 pieces. Smh The actual wing dings turned out to be the same exact thing just breaded and a dollar cheaper.
-
November 2023 by Todd Knisley
From the outside this looks like a very small, small-town pizza shop. It is relatively small inside with most orders seemingly being for pickup, but there are several tables inside for eating in.We ordered two "hoagies" (subs) and a small pizza. The bread used for the subs is great. Both subs were very good as was the thin NY-style pizza. We ordered a small pizza and what came out was very much more a "medium" in size and what some post-COVID places are calling "large".Street-side parking is easy and plentiful. The Steelers were being televised inside and everything worked out to be a good experience. I am usually in town once a year and will be sure to stop back in next year.Vegetarian options: Typical vegetarian sandwich and pizza options.
-
October 2023 by John Connell
It was a hole in the wall but in a good way.
-
July 2023 by Blaise Chapman
These people are dishonest and thieves. You've been warned... I ordered a pizza online at about 6:50PM one evening last month. The website said delivery at 7:45PM. Awesome! No problems so far... However, 8:30PM comes around and I still don't have my pizza so I call. The man who answered the phone was short with me, not polite at all and assured me my pizza was "On the way with the driver". That's fine! I get it! Place was busy and that's totally OK... However, when 9:20PM rolled around and I still had no pizza I called again. Same guy, same attitude. Pizza is "Almost there it's with the driver and will be with you any minute." Well... We are past the point of wanting the pizza now. Businesses need to be punished for bad service like this so I canceled my order and asked for a refund. The guy tried to talk me out of it but eventually said they'd refund "but it takes 7-10 business days" again... Fine! I don't care how long it took it was about principle not money at this point. So 7-10 days pass, no money. 15 days pass. No money. I then Facebook message the business and write essentially what I am writing here today and literally got ignored. Not even a reply. So I took it up with my bank and as it happens you can't really prove you didn't get your pizza so they kept the charge on my card. So here we are telling google what happened. Don't do business with Fellinis Pizza of Elizabeth. They're dishonest and thieves.
-
June 2023 by Rachael Waltonbaugh
Terrible. Ordered a gyro pizza. Came with onion and cheese. First and last time. Said must have been in the busy rush sorry. ?
-
May 2023 by Scott Sands
Got a pizza last night was completely discussing was the middle was almost straight soup had to eat it with a fork and spoon. Went in to get the food waited forever nobody what came out for a long time and some young kid came out like he did not care . Won't be ordering
-
April 2023 by Raven Martin
So I got a steak hoagie , the mushrooms, onions and peppers are raw and just thrown on the sandwich . And I asked for sauce on side so they wouldn't get soggy and they got delivered to me basically mush . Never again . So upset I wasted my money on this.
-
April 2023 by Matt M.
Delicious pizza loaded with toppings! Parking can be a little tricky.
-
February 2023 by Fw M.
Other than getting one order wrong everything else was good X allot times also the steak hoagies are fire pizza is good and the spicy chicken fries and cheese thing was in consistent which was my wife's
-
October 2022 by Talon
Second time ordering here, the first time I ordered they called me back an hour and fifteen minutes later to "make sure" they had a 3 item order correct and said it was because of the new guy, so I gave them the benefit of the doubt. Today I ordered 1 pizza and hot pepper cheese balls at 745 and it is now 925. Still no food, I called at 900 and was told they are waiting for the delivery driver to come back to pick up my order. I wonder how long the food sat there for. Never again
