Sheetz of Greencastle offers convenient, round-the-clock service with a wide variety of food, drinks, snacks, and other products. Customers can enjoy award-winning Made•To•Order® food and handmade Sheetz Bros. Coffeez® drinks while fueling their vehicles. The store is known for its clean bathrooms and friendly, top-notch service. Many appreciate the quick and efficient experience, especially during late-night visits when it’s a welcome stop on unfamiliar roads. The touchscreen ordering system helps pass the time, and self-checkouts provide a private option for those who prefer it. However, some customers are disappointed with menu changes, such as the removal of tots and onion rings, which affected their overall satisfaction. Others mention that certain food items, like the Italian cold cut, do not meet expectations due to limited meat portions. Despite occasional menu disappointments, Sheetz of Greencastle remains a popular choice for quick, convenient stops with a focus on quality food and friendly service.
