-
October 2023 by Katie Werner
Created a beautiful signet right for me, very responsive and helpful!
-
October 2023 by Matthew Ezersky
Peter helped me with a beautiful necklace. They have so many stunning pieces of jewelry, and they are really high-quality people. Courteous and honest.
-
August 2023 by Ibrahim
Peter is an absolutely delightful person - he is the sweetest guy you'll come across - if you're feeling down on a Friday - give Peter a ring, he will cheer you up. And don't forget to get rings from him - he is an absolutely amazing seller, and their products are top-notch!
-
December 2022 by Ryan Ercole
I was recommended by a good friend to go here for an engagement ring and I was not disappointed. Mr. Cooke was incredibly friendly and helpful. He walked me through the whole process (diamond education, sizing, bands, etc.) and helped me craft the perfect ring that could be incorporated with my grandmothers diamond.The ring turned out to be beautiful and I of course got a yes from my now fiancé.Thank you for everything!
-
December 2022 by Nina Bernstein
I had a horrible experience with Peter Cook yesterday. A friend of mine told me about his store. I went in there recently and Peter seemed very nice. I also was interested in a butterfly necklace which Peter was going to keep an eye out for me. When iI was there I asked him if he would be able to replace a tiny pave diamond in my David Yurman ring. He said yes and i asked him how much it would cost and he said $30.00. I said fine and I dropped it off the next day. I went in yesterday to pick up the ring and he told me it would cost $57.00. I said you told me it would cost $30 and he said well it cost more. He got very angry and I said why didn’t you call me then if it was going to be more and asked me if i was still interested before he did anything. He said, so you are not going to pay the bill? I said yes the $30 that you quoted me. I gave him my credit card and then he threw it on the floor. He told me to get out of the store and never come back.. I was literally in shock and could not believe that this was the same person i met the week before. i’ve never been treated like that ever. He is a disgrace and a horrible business person. The way I was treated was unforgivable. I would not recommend him to anyone and his jewelry is outrageously expensive. I hope no one ever has the same experience I had with Peter Cook.
-
December 2022 by Christian Ryan
Friendly staff and excellent/trusting service and I was able to get the most beautiful ring I've ever seen! Will certainly return !
-
August 2022 by Nina B.
I had a horrible experience today with Peter Cook. A friend of mine told me about his store. I went in there recently and Peter seemed very nice. I also was interested in a butterfly necklace that he was going to keep an eye out for it for me. When I was there I asked him if he could replace a tiny pavé diamond in a David Yurman ring. He said yes. I asked him how much he told me it would be $30. I said fine and I dropped it off the next day. I went in today to pick it up and he told me it would be $57. I said you told me it would be $30 and he said well it was more than that. He got very angry and I said to him why didn't you call me then if it was going to be more and asked me if I was still interested in replacing the stone with you before you did anything. He said to me so you are not going to pay the bill? I said yes, I am going to pay the price you quoted me. He got so angry he threw my credit card on the floor and said to get out of here and don't ever come back. I was literally in shock. I could not believe this was the same person that I met the week before. I have never been treated that way ever. Peter is a disgrace and the way I was treated was unforgivable. I would never give him my business. His jewelry was outrageously expensive. I hope no one has an experience like I did with his horrible person.
