Bagnall Shaw Insurance has been serving Downtown Lancaster since 2008 as a trusted independent insurance broker. They offer a wide range of insurance options, including home, auto, business, and life insurance, working with over 70 highly rated A+ carriers across America. Their real-time quote process allows customers to compare multiple quotes within just 15 minutes, helping them find the lowest rates. The company prides itself on providing competitive prices, often matching what customers would pay if calling carriers directly, with no agency fees and free quotes. Many clients have saved over $700 on average by switching to Bagnall Shaw. The staff, especially agents like Annie, are known for their quick, effective service and willingness to go above and beyond to meet customer needs. Customers appreciate how easy and hassle-free the process is, with Annie efficiently handling both personal and business insurance, often with minimal effort required from the client. Whether for personal auto, business, or other policies, clients consistently mention getting good prices and excellent service. Bagnall Shaw Insurance aims to make insurance shopping simple, affordable, and reliable, earning a strong reputation for customer satisfaction in Lancaster.
I had a great experience working with Garrett at Bagnall Shaw. He was quick to respond, easy to work with, and took the time to make sure I understood my coverage options. His professionalism and prompt service made the process smooth and hassle-free. Thanks again, Garrett!
August 2025
I’m glad yall have amazing people there like Annie she’s always available to help me with what I need her communication and the way she works with you is amazing. Definitely someone I will recommend y habla español que es un plus para los hispanos que no hablan mucho inglés en fin recomendable 🙏🏼
August 2025
Annie is the best. She gets things done quickly and effectively. I have worked with her for almost a year on my commercial and pesonal loan and she is always ready to adjusts my policies as i need. Very good service, very good work ethic and best prices in town. Thank you Annie for everything
