-
January 2024 by Annette
Best donuts anywhere. Made fresh every day and the cases are nearly empty when it's close to closing time.
-
October 2023 by Jacob McCracken
Been goin to Mays Donuts since I was a kid. 40 + yrs later and they're still my favorite!
-
August 2023 by Randy Hogue
Out of most everything
-
August 2023 by David
Always great donuts and service with a smile
-
May 2023 by Theresa N.
Very good donuts! The donuts are fresh and the service is always fast! Way better than Dunkin who's donuts are nothing but dry.
-
December 2022 by M “maddlyviolet” H
?3 words?Peanut. Butter. Donuts.
-
September 2022 by Katie S.
We have decided to try different donut places in the area and added May's to list a few weeks ago. Thankfully their New Castle location is near a relatives house. My parents were driving past today so stopped to get me a dozen. I can't speak of the actual bakery, but the donuts that they brought me had a great variety and tasted like homemade. Not bakery homemade, but like in a home kitchen, made with lots of love homemade. I loved that they were generous with their filling, icing and other toppings. I also like that they have been around for so many years and are a staple of the community!
-
July 2022 by Molly Hennon
?3 words?Peanut. Butter. Donuts.
-
April 2022 by Richard Splker
My brother was visiting from Maryland we stopped in and got him a dozen to take home
-
February 2022 by BizKit Plays
The donuts are fair priced.. giant cinnamon rolls and blueberry available certain days. The service...a beautiful thing!
-
December 2021 by Dee McKinney
Really should come down and talk to Peggy she worked at the May‘s donuts for many years downtown New Castle it was on E. Washington St. she made me a fresh pot of coffee asked me if I had the time to wait for a fresh pot of coffee and I did so we chatted a while did not get a donut because I’m not really much of a donut eater The coffee was good
-
July 2021 by Al Lutes
Donuts were good, but customer service was terrible. The lady behind the counter was rude and acted as if we were wasting her time. We were visiting from out of state and definitely will not go back to this location again when we come back. JoNell Lutes
-
May 2021 by Wayne Harper
Great donuts! Expected a better variety, but was not let down
-
February 2021 by Ian Spigler
Very nice small business. Fresh donuts and a friendly staff.
-
January 2021 by Jay Byler
Guys at work love there cream sticks, and twists.
