-
March 2024 by Kellyanne Conti
FAV PIZZA EVER! Pleasant atmosphere / employees. The guy with the mustache rocks,Megan not so much …
-
November 2023 by Catherine Malizia
Pizza Joe’s white veggie pizza is simply the best in town! When we travel and visit the area we always make a stop.
-
August 2023 by David Goff
Outstanding pizza!!
-
August 2023 by Tommy Jones
Ordered a bunch of pizzas for a work event and one of the pizzas was wrong called them and they wouldn't make me a new one said that's what I ordered which clearly I didn't and they wanted to charge me for another one. Thats real customer service thats something to be proud of. Highly recommend not spending a dime at that dump. Hope it goes out of business
-
August 2023 by Tommy J.
If I could rate it worse than this I would, ordered pizzas for a work event and they messed up one of the pizzas and I call them and they don't want to make me a new one for their mistake instead they would rather charge me for another one. That is some first class customer service there would recommend anyone to stay far away from this place. Can't wish hard enough for this store to go under as they are a bunch of clowns
-
July 2023 by Rare Assassin
Food is great and so is service,inside nice and clean and looks new wish they would use tht big blank wall they hv outside and put some art ? on it thr would be cool ?
-
April 2023 by Joshua McCracken
Literally been eating here all my life. Opened the same yr I was born. Everytime I come back to New Castle I gotta get a veggie and a stromboli
-
November 2022 by E Kramer
Best place to grab a quick slice. Sweet honey hot chicken pizza is fire. The best pepperoni rolls around
-
August 2022 by Will Smith
Pizza was usually good but then they gave me the wrong order and refused to admit let alone fix.
-
June 2022 by Gerry Smith
No one beats their veggie pizza it is incredible. I have a friend who is gluten free and she really liked their gluten free pizza.
-
February 2022 by Eric Kramer
Best place to grab a quick slice. Sweet honey hot chicken pizza is fire. The best pepperoni rolls around
-
November 2021 by April Marie
Ordered but had to cancel a few minutes later. The female that answered was rude and hung up on me. You don't have to be rude, I was giving you the courtesy of a call to cancel. Unnecessary.
-
November 2021 by Janice J
Highland Ave 200% ALWAYS
-
October 2021 by Cindy DeSalvo
Food was tasty
-
October 2021 by Jacob Houk
Good food. I wish they had more seating in their dining room like other Pizza Joe’s just seems a little congested
