Sheetz of New Castle is a 24/7 convenience store that offers kicked-up convenience with a focus on quality. Customers can enjoy award-winning Made•To•Order® food and handcrafted Sheetz Bros. Coffeez® drinks while fueling their vehicles. The store is clean and provides a variety of packaged snacks, drinks, tobacco, and CBD products. While some staff members are friendly and helpful, experiences with staff can vary, with some customers noting inconsistent service. The MTO food is generally good, though there are occasions when orders are incomplete or served cold. Despite these issues, many visitors find the food delicious and appreciate the welcoming atmosphere. The self-checkout, well-maintained bathrooms, and a beer cave enhance the shopping experience. Overall, Sheetz is a convenient stop for travelers and locals alike, with many expressing a desire to return.
