Rutter's #45 is a popular local establishment, known for its friendly and helpful staff. Customers praise the overnight team, especially Jack and Ursula, for their exceptional service, even when faced with challenging situations like a high volume of orders. While the food and service are generally praised, concerns have been raised about the workload placed on individual employees, with one customer noting that a single person had to handle 11 orders at once, along with cleaning and stocking duties. The business's focus on profits over employee well-being has also been criticized. Overall, Rutter's #45 offers a pleasant experience for many customers, though there are areas for improvement in staffing and management.