-
March 2024 by Cruel Joke
Must be under new ownership or something. Food is still pretty good, but the bar across the street as better food for a third of the price if you want to do pick up. I think they’re moving because of that. The staff are super nasty now, too. They used to have great service, but now you just get nasty comments and insults while they throw your food around like a ragdoll. The blonde teenager is particularly disrespectful. Can’t imagine why they would have her dealing with customers. She hates her job and wants you to know it’s your fault. Sad to see such a legendary place go downhill.
-
March 2024 by Tim W.
Could not get through on the phone to order. Went there to order and they forgot about my order and served people that arrived after me. I waited 30 mins for a sub and walked out. They make good subs but the service is very bad.
-
March 2024 by Justin Wenger
Their subs are second to none. Absolutely delicious and packed full. And very friendly service.
-
February 2024 by John Hall
Great
-
February 2024 by jeanmarie keller
Apparently they don't know their own menu. I ordered a REGULAR cheese for delivery and they sent veggie, cheese, and mushrooms. No future orders for me. I only gave 2 stars because my husband sandwich was fine.
-
February 2024 by Albert Hills
They where closed but there sign said open they are not true too to their word they do not live up to the original Newberry sub shop I can't give them a good rating because you can not order anything after 7:00pm that sucks.I did not get anything.
-
February 2024 by Brett Warkoski
Food is good. Location is okay. The inside is very small.
-
January 2024 by John Hannan
Dietary restrictions: Keto in a wrap
-
January 2024 by Bradley Loss
Wouldn’t let me place an order an hour before close. Place is absolute garbage!
-
January 2024 by Mr. Woods
Food was ok. I’ll probably buy it again.
-
January 2024 by Brenda Fessler
Delicious!!! Ham & Cheese Cosmo was SO good! Haven't been there for quite awhile; no longer work in Newberry. Wonderful food; great atmosphere; fantastic remodel!!!
-
January 2024 by Lois Hicks
Cheesesteaks are fantastic! Loaded with mouthwatering sirloin steak and FO ...and melted cheese.. So are the Cheese cosmos!ActuallyAll Their subs are great!
-
December 2023 by Ashley Turner
Food is always amazing and the employees are super
-
December 2023 by Cody McKibben
This place is legendary, authentic and delicious. The best hoagie shop in Williamsport and far beyond! Cheesesteaks, cosmos and Sherry’s red peppers are must haves. Don’t go too crazy with the pepper relish, it is hot!Pro tip - dine in for the best experience.
-
December 2023 by AmyEG1988
We are from wellsboro and spent a day in Williamsport. We had this on a list of places to try since it was recommended by friends. Did not disappoint. Very good cheesesteaks. Friendly service. We will be back.
