-
January 2024 by Pastor JC
Best pizza in Town!
-
January 2024 by Steve Dolan
My review is primarily focused on their ability to handle a party of 15 with an advanced reservation, which primarily ordered dinners. Despite the fact that their website touts they can handle parties of up to 70, they were overwhelmed. From the bar to the kitchen it was extremely disappointing. The only thing served in a timely fashion was a salad and 1 pizza. BTW, the rest of the restaurant was not busy at all. What irritated me the most was what appeared to be a woman manager, basically sitting at the bar the entire time offering little or no help to the overwhelmed staff. The chick marsala was good, the remainder of the dishes, served one by one over an hour or more, were at best fair. For dessert we wanted to order cannolis. They had only one for us to split. If you wish to dine there, keep it simple, pizza and beer.
-
January 2024 by Jackie Bluebell
This was one of our favorite local lunch spots, but the staff changed, so we started going on different days to hopefully get the better staff. The last time we visited was the last time I will ever visit. The server was not only rude, but nasty to another diner nearby. The food is overpriced and mediocre.
-
November 2023 by Kassandra Hoffman
Staffing is the worst there, specifically one server. Amber. Terrible establishment. The turnover rate is never a good thing either. I would not go there nor would I respect the manager who came in & disrespected me & my friends after their server verbally assaulted me to say I need to leave. My four friends & I came there and had menus after being sat, which was “sit wherever”. Mind you the pizza guy was passive aggressive also & talked very rudely. I have prior issues with Amber being she had me deposit a $1,036 check into my acct via mobile from Nycp to give her the money since she couldn’t get a bank acct. I sent it to her via cash app & she deposited it somewhere in Hampton behind my back when I had asked her to write void. I looked at my acct & contacted amber as I had trusted her at the time & low & behold she ignored the situation. I took it into my own hands & contacted the owners of NYCP & they are the ones who gave me the information that it had been cashed. My bank then said it would take time to find out why..a couple days later, showed duplicate presentation & went as far as finding out what bank she had it cashed at. Unfortunately, the check had bounced in which I contacted the managers as I was working there & just wanted it to be made right but she continues to lie even though we all really who who she is. She still to this day hasn’t paid me back but continues you to talk about the way people tip her & so forth. I wonder why. She got not only my hard working money but she got her check as well. Also to be honest, I didn’t even want to go to this restaurant but my friends said I want pizza & it was the closest to us. Terribly ran, horrible staff hired needless to say. Experience it yourself, do NOT recommend going at ALL! If you do, save yourself the drive & go to Buckwalter NYCP. Jessica, the manager, has always taken care of me whereas Natalie, the one at Belfair does not & always states that’s the Belfair store is hers as if she owns the spot, which she does not. She is extremely rude to employees as I’ve experienced it myself & so have others. Sotake my advice, try another pizza spot such as the BUCKWALTER location in Nycp, Giuseppe’s, Local Pie, or Uppercrust. Much better service and quality of food.
-
November 2023 by George Ingram
Both of the locations at which I've eaten have been fantastic.
-
November 2023 by Laura VanHorn
Great pizza but I was so cold in the store the evening we went. Fans going full blast—it was uncomfortable.
-
November 2023 by Tiffany T.
Staff was attentive and nice. I had to wait a little bit for my takeout and they kept me updated and kept checking on it. Turns out I had to wait for the slices because they made a fresh pizza. It tasted phenomenal!
-
November 2023 by Katherine Russo
This is my go to pizza, I love how when I pick it up for delivery they show me the bottom...It means they really care... I did not notice the time when I called to place an order last week at 8:56 pm, and they were still happy to serve even though they closed at 9. BTW if your hungry for a meatball parm...there's is the best...I do recommend eating it there though.
-
September 2023 by emma roach
from new york and we were looking for a good pizza place to try so we came here, everything was amazing! pizza was phenomenal and service was fantastic. definitely will be coming back!!
-
August 2023 by Eileen Goldberg
Food always good and servers are as well. I prefer going to this location, even though it's about the same distance to Buckwalter.
-
August 2023 by Terri Naber
Being a Brooklyn girl living in the heart of Dixie, it's been a real challenge to find decent pizza (among other comfort foods!)NYCP is, by FAR, the best pizza and Italian food in the low country. They definitely know how to prepare and cook New York Italian food! The sauce is not too tangy, not too sweet (as most southern pizza is -gross!-) and it's obvious they take great pride in their New York heritage ?The regular round pie is as close as you will get to Brooklyn pizza down here. Trust me, I've tried MANY! We drive 45 minutes there and back just for pizza!Also of note: their arancini (rice balls) are ON POINT, as are the zucchini sticks, veal parm, and eggplant rollatini. The salad with house dressing is also DELISH!I highly recommend NYCP! We go to the Bluffton location, but I've heard they are all equally wonderful.
-
August 2023 by P Robins
I’m no longer going to purchase a pizza there - while a good pie, it’s simply not worth almost $35 for a large 3-topping pizza - not even wood
-
August 2023 by Don S
Lousy service! No advice on what to order or stay away from. Our pizza was steaming when it was served, and the crust was soggy. We ordered it with calamata olives which were insufferably salty. Prosciutto also very salty. Sausage was thankfully flavorless (not too salty). The pizza was so water logged that slices came apart as we tried to put them in the to-go container. It was in contention for the worst pizza I have ever had. And the service was to match. Will NEVER GO BACK!!!
-
August 2023 by Michele Kipar
As a transplanted Northerner who had the blessing to experience NYC food most of my life this is the best place to go!Love this pizza!!Sauce is homemade and the pizza dough has perfect taste and texture if you’re searching for that New York Italian experience.Super friendly and competent staff no matter the time of day!
-
August 2023 by Stuart Zalud
We have been loyal NY City Pizza customers for many years. My only suggestion is pricing should be reviewed. I realize Inflation plays a role but the costs seem to have skyrocketed. We are now utilizing the take-out les frequently. Seems like the portions have also been curtailed some. We just do not call as often because of the cost.