-
April 2024 by Donna F.
Over priced ice cream sandwhich. Stopped by after dinner on walk back to hotel. Young woman working didn't greet when walked in just "are you guys ready". It was a premade sandwhich that wasn't anything special. I suggest off tracks ice cream if looking for some good ice cream
-
March 2024 by Juliette L.
What a gem nestled in the heart of downtown Charleston! This cute little ice cream sandwich shop is an absolute delight for anyone with a sweet tooth. The variety here is astounding! With close to 40 different flavor combinations, it makes it hard to choose. The employee working was incredibly friendly and gave us some of her recommendations, because we were a little overwhelmed. We ended up going with the Cookie Dough, which was vanilla ice cream, chocolate mouse and cookie dough chunks, sandwiched between 2 chocolate cookies. Would highly recommend!!
-
March 2024 by Catherine B.
DARN! I was so excited for this ice cream sandwich and it was beautiful but it just wasn't as good as I wanted it to be. I got the cookies n cream sandwich and that ice cream was really good, but whatever the icing or cream is that they used above and below the cookies n cream to stick to the cookie was weird and I did not like it. Hate to say it but I threw most of it away because of that :( I would for sure just order their cookies n cream ice cream in a cup or cone if that's an option next time.
-
March 2024 by Chandler Dent
Peace Pie is unique & one of a kind with their flavor combinations. I highly recommend their strawberry shortcake flavor, it’s not too sweet & overall super refreshing!
-
March 2024 by Curtis J.
Just okay. Was expecting a better vibe from the place but it was just...blah. Got the Peach Ice Cream one, and it was okay. Sweeter than I expected. Actually, shoulda figured something was up, taste wise, when it was technically labeled Peach Cream. Anyway, the server was also past ready to go home, and showed it, combined with the mediocre desert and this highly anticipated visit was a fail. Glad after 2 years of discovering its existinance that I at least finally got to check it out.
-
February 2024 by Nana C.
This small ice cream sandwich shop is bright and inviting. The pies, frozen ice cream sandwiches with a layer of pie filling, are thick with a thin cookie crust. The chocolate mint was delicious but difficult to eat because the ice cream was hard. It would probably be better on a warm day when ice cream melts faster. Service was prompt.
-
February 2024 by Jill M.
Staff were so nice. The ice cream sandwiches are BIG & delicious! I'm obsessed with mint chocolate chip & this hit the spot!
-
February 2024 by Mark Carson
I was Charleston for a week unfortunately very ill for several of days, Peace Pie was outside my hotel and seemed like the best option for my ravaged stomach. I literally lived on them for three days and tried probably half the options. All of them were amazing, though the blueberry cobbler was the stand out, absolutely fantastic. I am so sad that I live 7 states away.
-
November 2023 by michael villarreal
I was really excited to try this place because it was on a ton of tourist recommendations when I was searching up things to do. But man the woman at the counter was beyond rude and there was no other customer even there. After I asked what size the sandwiches were she didn’t even look at me or say anything and just held one up as she continued with whatever work she was doing. No hello or any communication as I walked in or at any point of me being in the store. They were out of almost every sandwich. Extremely awful experience and just really brought me down on our trip. There’s a nice little Italian dessert shop a couple doors down from here that I recommend.
-
November 2023 by Laurie F.
Huge ice cream cookie sandwiches! One was big enough that my husband and I split it in 2 and it was plenty. They have so many yummy sounding flavors and it's all home made which is nice. The service I fast and the shop is cute. We got the Elvis which was great, we'd come back again if we lived local!
-
October 2023 by Dena Cooper
Cute little ice cream sandwich shop on Meeting street right across the street from Fig. They require a few minutes to warm up, which was nice considering what ice cream usually does in the heat. These didn't melt super quickly, and I was able to eat it with some sort of dignity.I liked the crunchy cookie with the ice cream. It held its shape well through several bites, and didn't melt or drip all over. I thought it was really good, but who doesn't like cookies and ice cream...We ate sitting outside on a bench on Meeting street, which happens to be a prime location for people watching. Overall a nice experience.
-
October 2023 by Tiarra T.
I've ordered here a few times. The service is quick. The sandwiches are frozen well, so they hold for a while if you want to take them home and freeze them for later. My favorite is the vanilla sandwich. I especially like the custard between the ice cream sandwich and the ice cream. Looking forward to trying other flavors.
-
October 2023 by Anne O.
So tasty - a fancy ice cream sandwich. The cookie is thin enough to hold the ice cream, but not overpower the bite. It is also firm enough to hold the sandwich together until it is gone. For my first time I tried the Creme Brulee sandwich and truly can't wait to try this spot again.
-
September 2023 by Sam Sachs
A great way to beat the heat while visiting Charleston! I love the variety of flavors they have, and really liked the caramel option we picked. Service was super friendly and very quick as well! Just make sure to eat it as fast as possible if it's hot outside, because they do melt fast!
-
September 2023 by Shane V.
I was a bit let down by my ice cream sandwich. It was very hard which wasn't that enjoyable. I expected more of a soft outside like a cookie on an ice cream sandwich.
