-
March 2024 by Mary Williamson
Wonderful place to eat!! Walk in the front door and you hear music. You can sit on that side with the music or sit on the other side and barely hear the music. Your preference. Love that! Excellent service! Love that they have paper placemats on the table! (Somewhere for your utensils to sit, for germaphobes like me?)If you bring little kids, they can color and have their picture taped to the wall. We had the side salad and we each had a small pizza. It was enough to feed a family of 4!! We had to box up the leftovers. They serve you a lot of food!! Quality and quantity of food matches the cost.Very clean restroom and I always say that tells me something about the kitchen. We will be back!
-
March 2024 by Joshua Fineberg
Absolutely a gem of a restaurant. This is more than a pizzeria. The shrimp portafino is immaculate. The Cuban sub is incredible. The presentation is good. The staff are friendly. If Gordon Ramsay were to eat in hartsville SC, I’d recommend him this restaurant. Best subs, best pizza, best Italian food (probably the only AUTHENTIC Italian food in the county) GO HERE. You will not regret it. The head chef is an Italian man who can not even speak English, so you know it’s good.
-
March 2024 by Tiffaney Johnson
I went outside the box this time and ordered something a friend of mine was telling me was really good. A cheeseburger sub. Another place in town serves this and it is my absolute favorite but their prices have gotten so high. I was skeptical but I ordered it the same way I get the other and it was so good! NY by the slice is such a great and affordable place and you can tell because they are usually pretty busy when we go. Thank you NY by the slice for being one of our constants in town!
-
March 2024 by Kass
I placed an order over the phone for pickup based on the menu prices google has listed. I went to get my food with exactly what google said it would cost and the young lady at the register informed me that the online prices on google are wrong and from years ago. She was very kind and accepted the amount I had. This restaurant has great food and great service. I highly recommend it!
-
February 2024 by E. Robert Thomas
Great local restaurant with wonderful staff and awesome food. Our house's favorite item is the meatball sub. Thank you all for being a vital part of our
-
January 2024 by Stephanie Young
The food was absolutely delicious.. The staff was friendly and attentive. We have gone back 3 times and will continue. 30 min drive is so worth it. It's reasonably priced too.
-
January 2024 by Matt Flintrop
This is a really nice little hometown place. The portions were large in the food was was good for sure. The weight staff couldn’t have been any nicer. I was a little disappointed in the pizza just because I had high expectations. I had the meat lovers, and it was only OK. I bet the specialty pizzaswould have been a better choice. My wife had the Philly cheesesteak, and I shared some and thought it was as good as any. I wish I would have thought to have asked them to toast the bun though.
-
January 2024 by Jacob Crenshaw
Good place to have a meal with friends and loved
-
December 2023 by Henderson Tyndall
This was our first visit here. Hands down the best supreme pizza I've ever eaten. The crust, edge and bottom was perfect. Would definitely go back.
-
December 2023 by Pam Flowers
I ordered three pizzas,( vegetable, cheese, & pepperoni with mushrooms), garlic knots, and chicken parmigiana. Everything was really good! Thank youVegetarian options: I love vegetable pizza!!
-
December 2023 by Tony Howell
Had the buffalo chicken salad. Very good.
-
December 2023 by Jodee Hutchinson
Always delicious and cozy atmosphere.
-
December 2023 by Steven Watson
Great service and all things considered, a tasty pie. Definitely a place I'd return to whenever in the area.
-
December 2023 by Evelyn Rivera
I really like New York Pizza they're very professional and the food is
-
December 2023 by Dee Stephney
My favorite go to place whenever I'm in the area visiting. Best NY style pizza I have been able to find in a
