Casey's in Webster, SD, located at 1000 Main St, is known for its delicious pizza made with fresh ingredients, including made-from-scratch dough and real mozzarella cheese. Customers enjoy a variety of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials alongside their fuel services. While the pizza is praised and the staff is friendly, some have noted that the gas pump screens need repair. The employees are appreciated for their kindness and make customers feel welcome, ensuring a pleasant experience. Overall, Casey's is a beloved spot for great food and friendly service.
Employees need to stay home if sick. The kitchen help looked like you could catch something from them 50' away. GROSS I left hungry
March 2025
Casey's has great pizza and decent facilities. As others have said though, the screens at the gas pumps absolutely need to be fixed/replaced. The screens are so faded that I can't follow the prompts to complete a fuel transaction.
August 2023
We’ve been ordering pizza here for years and have never had a complaint. Tonight our pizza was made incorrectly. Samantha was so kind and made us a new pizza. To say that my preteen boys were ecstatic would be an understatement….❤️
