-
March 2024 by An L
Oh my gosh these pies are truly so good! Wonderful experience. The key lime pie is delicious. Not super tangy or tart. The white cream on top is so light and airy, lightly sweetened. Just really good. The pecan pie is delicious as well! Not overly sweet. Everything was really delicious! Much smaller pies than I expected but still overall a good experience.
-
January 2024 by Amber McCord
My husband and daughters each got a pie today and they were in love! They tried the key lime, coconut cream, and chocolate cream pie! I tried a bite of the key lime and it was so delicious! We will definitely be back!
-
January 2024 by Peter G
Owner refused to exchange a pie that tasted terrible. $30 in the trash. With margins like that, take the pie back, keep the customer happy. Owner did offer two small pies
-
December 2023 by A. Bosillo
Picked up two pies the Tuesday before Thanksgiving. Had easily placed and paid for my order online a few days prior. Pickup was quick, they had pies wall-to-wall. Everyone loved the Pumpkin and Apple pie. Pumpkin pie did say it’s only available 10/16-12/31
-
December 2023 by Trudy Casteleiro
Absolutely the best pecan and pumpkin pies we ever tasted.
-
December 2023 by Brian Hall
Ordered online and figured I'd run up to get my pies before a business meeting that I had. I totally missed the "ready time" notification I received. long story short, I got there 2 hours before I was supposed to and Sheila immediately took the time to put my pies together and quickly had me on my way so I didn't miss my meeting!
-
December 2023 by Moe Iwasa
ABSOLUTELY THE BEST PIE EVER!!!! I ordered 5 mini pies( coconut cream, apple, I-40, pumpkin, and key lime) for thanksgiving. They were literally the best pies I had in my life!! I loved the pumpkin and apple. My husband and my brother loved the I-40 and coconut cream. Everything was perfect and I cannot wait to go back to order the bigger sizes!!
-
December 2023 by Avi Huerta
this gem caught me and my boyfriend’s attention. We were welcomed as soon as we got inside the service was great. We got 4 mini pies they were so good and cuteeee!!! we will for sure be back!!!!!
-
September 2023 by Tyler Williams
It really makes NO SENSE how good these pies are?
-
August 2023 by Megan Vollmer
Thank you for the delicious sweet treats! We will definitely be back.
-
August 2023 by Nate Cates
Drove over here to try their gluten free and was told they don't have any in stock and you have to call 24 hours in advance.
-
August 2023 by D D.
I'm in town about 10 days a month. I have been stopping by to try the chocolate/chocolate ganache thumbprint cookies for months. I don't want to buy a dozen because I'll end up eating all of the cookies, but I will allow myself a couple of cookies. Today I'm elated that they made my quest for these cookies and I bought two chocolate/ chocolate, and two plain/chocolate ganache. I am thrilled to report that my impression of what the chocolate/chocolate ganache were going to taste like has extremely exceeded my expectations. These cookies were tasty, delicious, and decadent! I have also tried almost every pie except for the coconut one because I've never been a fan of coconut. The pies are truly fantastic too. Hence, I would highly recommend this pie shop for their pies and cookies. Thank you ladies!!!
-
August 2023 by CM C.
We tried the peanut butter pie, the Keylime pie, and the peach pie, all three were delicious. The mini pies are just wonderful, I agree. They have a great ratio of pie to crust, and the crust is really wonderful. If you like pie, you've got to give these guys a try
-
July 2023 by Madison T.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is the place to be if you're craving the best apple pie of your life! Seriously, I can't even put into words how incredible it was.Their apple pie is a slice of pure bliss. The crust? Flaky perfection. The filling? Bursting with juicy apples, cinnamon, and just the right amount of sweetness. I've never tasted anything like it. This pie skyrocketed to the top of my all-time favorites list.The folks at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop are amazing too. They greeted me with big smiles and Their passion for pies is contagious, and it made the experience even sweeter.So, here's the deal: if you're a pie lover or just someone who appreciates damn good dessert, you need to check out Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. Trust me, you won't regret it. From the mind-blowing apple pie to the friendly vibes, this place is a hidden gem that deserves all the love it can get.Don't waste another minute. Head over to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop and treat yourself to a slice of apple pie heaven. You'll thank me later.
-
July 2023 by Candis Culver
Buttermilk Sky Colleyville, Tx. is my go to for pies!! Their crust is the best I’ve had since my Grandmother’s,!! My favorite is chocolate cream, with whipped meringue, in a pie crust!! It’s a special order, so I call the night before, and it’s ready in the morning. I give pies as gifts, whom they all love! They have single, and regular size pies!!! The Woman owned business, and staff are amazing!!!
