Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is a welcoming and family-friendly business known for its delicious pies and excellent customer service. Customers praise the shop for its friendly staff, especially mentioning an employee named Steve who provides kind and helpful service. The shop offers a variety of pies, including key lime, coconut cream, snickerdoodle, banana cream, chocolate cream, peanut butter cream, lemon cream, and blueberry pie Cloud 9. Many customers enjoy their mini pies, with some buying multiple sets due to their quality and flavor variety. The pies are described as unique, tasty, and perfect for different occasions, including birthdays. The shop also offers gluten-free options and maintains a clean, inviting atmosphere. Additional conveniences include plenty of parking and a drive-thru window. Customers often return for more, praising the pies’ taste and the shop’s friendly environment. Overall, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop stands out for its great service, delicious pies, and warm community feel, making it a favorite spot for families and pie lovers alike.
The Pies were absolutely wonderful and the lady was very nice !
May 2026
Pies I ordered were very good. I will definitely be back.
February 2026
So this past Friday I messed up on my dad’s order thinking I was gifting him his favorite pie ( Key Lime) but found out he loves (Lemon Meringue). He’s very picky so I felt horrible I had dropped the ball but by my surprise he LOVED the key lime pie! Said that’s the first key lime pie that wasn’t too tart or tangy!
