Nutty's Peanut Butter is a fun little store and a must-stop for peanut butter lovers. Customers can sample all the many delicious flavors and tasty selections before purchasing, which is highly recommended. The owner is very sweet, nice, friendly, and helpful. People leave with jars of peanut butter and lots of other goodies like brownies, rice crispies, fudge, candy, ice cream, cookies, cake balls, and chocolate covered things. Everything is super delicious and a big hit. It is a great little stop and a must-have if you are in the area or town.
I got the peanut butter brickle and the chocolate marble. Both are fantastic but the brickle is my absolute favorite. The nice gentleman in the store was so patient and polite. He let us try all of the peanut butters. We left with 6 jars between our 2 parties. Yet another beautiful reason to visit Jefferson!
December 2025
The date and walnut PB is superb! Love the old timey vibe of this place.
August 2025
THE BEST PEANUT BUTTER IVE EVER HAD! I got the “White chocolate chip” peanut butter today, and let me tell you this is the best stuff ever! I don’t know if it will even make it to bread, I can eat this straight out of the jar! The owners are also wonderful, can’t go wrong supporting family owned!
