-
March 2024 by Mustang Man
Great pizza, and staff! Thanks
-
March 2024 by Kali Cochran
Absolutely delicious! Everything is made from scratch and tastes so good!! We got cheese sticks, the chicken bacon ranch and a pepperoni pizza with mushrooms!! Mmm! It is definitely worth the drive!
-
February 2024 by T Bizzy
This is New York style pie, go for a classic cheese or pepperoni. You won’t find another place like this in the western states especially in Utah. Pizza dough/ sauce and marinara is out of this world. Best pizza on this planet hands down! Small town USA
-
November 2023 by T Schneider
Best NY-style pizza I've ever had! Now, I know what your thinking...thats like saying the best well-done steak you've ever had. Spot on. NY-style pizza is inherently inferior(like everything in NYC)...but they did a fantastic job of it! It was very very good! Fresh tasting ingredients and great service. If google let me give fractional points, I'd give them 4.8, because they only have NY style. But it really is good. Now if we could just get them to stop handicapping themselves, and make a Detroit-style(or even just a neutral style crust like a Marco's)...that would be heaven. But I digress....stop in this place and have a great pizza!!!
-
October 2023 by Mary Rosa
Didn’t feel very welcome at first, felt like I was in one of those places where tourists should stay away. That impression soon was gone and I was so glad we stop there for lunch. The waiter was nice and gave us a great tip on which pizza to get, and it was an amazing pizza. Probably the best pizza I have ever had. If you’re around, please get in and get stuffed!
-
October 2023 by Mike Green
Amazing pizza. Crust is cooked to perfection. The staff treated us so well. Kind of a dive from the outside but the food was incredible.
-
September 2023 by Richard Savage
I worked in New York for 3 years and this is the best New York Pizza I have found in Utah. Also have some excellent calzone. My wife and I split a small Pizza.
-
September 2023 by Skyler Parker
Amazing new York style pizza. Very fast service. Their servers are very polite too.
-
September 2023 by Blake Baker
This place is worth driving too. Fantastic food. Lots of options. Pizza was excellent. I loved the garlic cheese and the Italian was very good too.Bonus points if you recognize the red chairs they use. ?Our waiter was terrific and very helpful.
-
September 2023 by Colleen McCormick
Wow! We were filling up at the gas across the street and noticed Tomatoes Pizza Pie. Honestly, didn’t look like much, but my search for reviews was very positive so we decided to give it a try. I am so glad. We ordered pizza and salad. The salad was fresh and the dressing was awesome. Pizza arrived and it was fantastic. The best pizza I’ve had in awhile. I’d return in a heartbeat
-
September 2023 by Alexander P.
Just a handful of guys jamming away slinging out hot pies! Pizza and cheese sticks were awesome! Good atmosphere - was a tad bit smoky but reasonable and the staff was slammed for a Thursday evening. The pizza was amazing to say the least! Great crust, sweet sauce and perfect amount of cheese. If you are near I-70 or in the area it is worth the drive 100%.
-
September 2023 by Linda E.
Excellent place for pizza. Staff is friendly and experienced. They ck on you after your food arrives too. They are very busy!! Parking is on the street Restaurant is clean...nothing fancy!Sometimes run out of items ( like tonite it was lettuce) You can see them toss the pizza...outdoor seating.with umbrellas. Raviolis are tasty; i recommend the specialty pizza... which has about everything on it. It was done in a timely manner and delicious! A small pizza fed two people. Right on the highway so very convenient if you're traveling Will eat here again
-
September 2023 by Raymond stone
We went in with 16 people, service was great food was good , everything went well.
-
September 2023 by Agnieszka Cruz
By far the best pizza I have ever had, and I've been to Italy. It's absolutely amazing, from the first bite to the last crumb from the crust. I will visit Utah again just to eat here! And the staff was very nice too, which made the experience even beter.
-
September 2023 by Nancy stone
We went in with 16 people, service was great food was good , everything went well.
