-
February 2024 by J.W. Rowell
Pizza is good, a touch crunchy. I can't say the same for the other food. Everything was significantly overcooked. Your ovens are too hot. The Boneless chicken could've broken a tooth. Garlic knots, more like hockey pucks. We have eaten here a couple of times and have had the same experience. I would generally bring the food back or make a call to NYPO. That wasn't an option at the time. I guess you could ask for your food a little less scorched. I honestly will look for other options in the area. And try again later.
-
December 2023 by Jared “Sweaters” Bellfield
It's been a bit since I have been there, it was rather tasty, it was clean, and the staff was great.
-
November 2023 by Kyle Gray
Very poor customer service. Ordered a stromboli with only pepperoni and bacon over the phone. Got home and it was made the standard way. Called and asked for one to be remade as it didn't have the modifications we asked and paid for. They told us because they made it the way they had it on the menu they wouldn't remake because it was "just a miscommunication" and we could call tomorrow and see if the manager will remake it for us... Simple problem that could have been easily fixed, but instead Im the one that paid for the "miscommunication"
-
November 2023 by Xoe
Best pizza you can get in Colchester!
-
November 2023 by Brian N F.
Great food and service. Recently moved back to New England and have enjoyed all of the appetizers we have tried, the pizza, and the subs. Staff is friendly and delivery is on point. Can't ask for more!
-
October 2023 by Kim F.
Food was fresh, delicious, and delivered super quick. Pizza was yummy and the Italian sub was perfect. Also got an order of the buffalo and the dry rub wings. Outstanding! We will definitely order again
-
October 2023 by Kimberly C
I have never had a bad experience here. The staff is always smiling and friendly. They are very knowledgeable about the food here. If you can't decide what you want, they are happy to make suggestions centered around your likes and dislikes. The pizza in my opinion is one of the best I've ever had. They have a variety of slices every day, and come out nice and hot. The 18" pie can feed a family of four no problem. The crust is amazing. It has a beautiful crispy soft texture. Easy to fold and eat on the go. They always have the perfect amount of toppings/cheese ratio. Their red sauce has a great tomato flavor, not sweet, with plenty of spices to balance it out. I will go out of my way to order from NYPO. If you've never been here give them a try.
-
October 2023 by Donna Demag
Best pepperoni pie, loaded with pepperoni? Who knew. It was greatVegetarian options: AwesomeDietary restrictions: Anything you need, gluten free etcParking: Drive up to door pup
-
September 2023 by Dave
Great pizza, fast service. Super friendly
-
September 2023 by Jennie B.
Great food. Quick delivery and hand off with a smile. Buffalo chicken salad is very good!
-
July 2023 by David K.
We ordered a large cheese pizza, a medium house Margherita, and the mozzarella sticks. The service was very good when I picked up and unlike other reviewers, my online order was on-time and hot.My relative from New York said that if pizza is similar to what you would find in Lake Placid, it's not necessarily "New York" pizza and that these pies fit that description. He did however really like the mozzarella sticks. I agree with his assessment, I didn't care for either pie, although I felt the house Margherita was better than the plain.I think both pies could've used more cheese, and the crusts both were a bit stale in texture. Honestly, it reminded me of dominoes. Good service and a nice atmosphere but in my opinion the actual pizza needs some real work.
-
June 2023 by ted hanbridge
Have done pizza takeout for years & very satisfied. BUT, did subs 2day & not good. Rolls were very stale & maybe had 2 ounces of turkey & 1 thin slice of cheese & 4got tomates. Very disappointed!!!
-
May 2023 by Paul Varricchione
NYPO was sooo good in 2000/2001. They did this crazy thing with the sauce... There was something in it that was just "different". I didn't go for some years because it was out the way. I'm not sure if ownership changed but I went back in like 2017 and wanted a large pizza. They had a special that night on pepperoni. I asked if I could just get a cheese for the special price but they told me the deal was for pepperoni (thought I'd be saving them money. Maybe they had some pepperoni that was close to date). I gave up on the place for a while but tried again the date of this review. I got a large cheese. 18 plus, dollars. Paid with a 20 dollar bill and said "keep the change" and took it home. All I can say about this pizza is that it was like a medium sized pizzas Ingredient portions stretched to be a large. Barely any sauce or cheese. Shameful. That was it for me. Stinks because I hate chain pizza and that's all I have close to me other than NYPO. Oh well. For the price, a home made pizza is more rewarding.
-
May 2023 by Lurdes S
First time trying & the Pizza was delicious!!! & the wings were really good as well!!! Everything was delivered hot & fresh..Will definitely be ordering again! My new fav pizza spot!
-
April 2023 by Christine Sabens
Went in to get a single slice as I often do and never had a bad
