-
October 2024 by Carol Stockton
Please understand 4 stars from me is a very favorable review. This place was GREAT! The rooms are, apparently, very idiosyncratically decorated…ours looked like a back country lodge and I understand others are all equally fun. The room was very large, with a nice sitting area, desk area and separate sleeping area and a huge, nicely appointed bathroom.
The food was amazing. These people are evil! They leave out fresh baked pasties for those of us who can’t last until the delicious breakfast. The scones! The muffins! And no one keeping count of my gluttony! Need I say more?
-
June 2024 by Evelyn Jordan
Where do I even start with how perfect this girl's trip was!? This is one of the most amazing groups of hotel staff I have ever met. EVERYONE was SO nice and accommodating to our group who was celebrating my best friend's birthday. They helped us book massages (which were incredible), they helped order a birthday cake, have champagne in the room and make dinner reservations. We even got a tour of some of the beautiful rooms at the Inn! Food and drinks were absolutely incredible at both Tracks and the main dining. We stayed in the Hayloft Suite which was huge and beautiful! The Inn is gorgeous and well taken care of. We enjoyed the local farmers market, warren falls and warren store across the street. I can't say enough about how nicely we were treated and how wonderful our trip was. We became such good friends with the entire staff and they really made the trip perfect. I can't wait to come back with my husband to enjoy a romantic weekend away together. THANK YOU TO EVERYONE AT THE PITCHER INN!!
Nearby activities: Warren Falls, Warren general store, Mad River on the Green
-
June 2024 by Leslie Robinson
My husband and I had a lovely 2-night stay at The Pitcher Inn in
late May 2024. Our room was spacious and beautifully furnished with antiques. The staff, especially Sharon, was very helpful suggesting places to see around the area. The main dining room was not open the Monday and Tuesday we were there. Dinner in the Tavern and our breakfasts were both very good. We especially enjoyed seeing the Shelburne Museum - it is worth the drive. The location is charming although a bit isolated. A dinner one night at the new restaurant Crag and Roe in nearby Waitesfield was excellent. A relaxing charming place to stay in Vermont.
-
February 2024 by Cathy Cashman
We have been coming here for our Anniversary for the past few years and have always loved it .. This time was a huge disappointment. Called a week ahead for a reservation which they didn’t have but did honor which we appreciate. The Charcuterie board was sparse and jam tasted like smuckers. Menu was very small and choices weren’t great . My husband had the pasta dish which was the worst I’ve ever tasted . It cost $36 and probably cost the restaurant a $1 to make . My halibut was the only good thing about the meal .. but I thought it was still incredibly small proportion for price. Waitress was okay. For An upscale restaurant in Vermont too pretentious and nothing to back it up.
-
February 2024 by Antonio Reis
After many years of wanting to visit, my first experience with Pitcher Inn was disappointing. My partner and I stayed in Warren at another inn but tried to visit the Pitcher for drinks and a snack. The reception staff wouldn't seat us and were quite abrupt and rude about it. I've never been turned away from an establishment by a haughty suited receptionist holding a snow shovel but I guess this is Vermont. Weird place.
-
January 2024 by Gabrielle Gifford
Had an amazing stay at the Pitcher Inn over MLK weekend. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel comfortable prior to and during our stay. Fresh croissants every morning were top notch.We didn’t get a chance to eat in their more casual pub restaurant “Tracks” and that is our only regret! Hope to make it back one day.
-
January 2024 by Anastasiia Kiseleva
We didn't have the opportunity to stay at the hotel, but we had a fantastic experience dining at the restaurant. The food was exceptional, and the service was top-notch. Our waiter was very attentive and made sure we had everything we needed. If you're looking for a special dining experience in this area, I highly recommend this restaurant.
-
January 2024 by mayu h
When we made a reservation, the lady asked the upstairs formal dining or casual place downstairs. We said upstairs formal dining for our Jan 1 family dinner event. The management representative at the front desk did not seem sorry that formal dining was closed on the date and we drove 50min to get there. Also the coffee tasted sour and old.
-
October 2023 by Kris Merchant
If you visit the mad river valley and you are looking for premium dining and service you will love it. Quintessential Vermont. If you don’t love it, I’ll pay for your dinner. (Well not really, but if I was with you I would).
-
October 2023 by Julie's bites
2023: the addition of heat lamps on the porch made very comfortable to done outside in late September.
2021: Another excellent meal. This time we ate on the porch, as we prefer to eat outside due to Covid. The porch has a handful of tables with terrific views. It was lovely. The duck breast and octopus appetizer were particularly outstanding. Butter poached lobster was also nice. Great service and a fine meal.
2019: Outstanding food experience. Scalop appetizer was particularly good. Elk chop was flavorful. Presentation and side dishes were excellent. We will be back again!
2018:Food was good but not outstanding. Friendly and superb service.
2017: Outstanding food, great service, beautiful location.
-
October 2023 by Helen Camia
We come here every year, and each year beats the year before! don’t ever skip tracks!
Food and drinks: Chimichurri steak is magnificent
-
October 2023 by Bruce S
Food and drinks: Tracks pub... Live music!
-
October 2023 by Chris Barker
Excellent meal and preparation. Serving sizes are delicate.
-
October 2023 by Cam Curland
Absolutely beautiful little inn tucked into the mountains in Warren, VT. Lies right along a creek with aqua blues hues against the rocks beneath. Right across the street a perfect place to grab food or drinks before heading out on daily adventures. The Pitcher inn has a private back porch and a garden with grapevines hanging. A great spot to take some downtime.
-
October 2023 by Chat
We chose the formal dining area. We were seated inside but had a view of the backyard and terrace which they lit up nicely at night. Service was excellent. I had the scallops and my husband had the salmon. Both were delicious. Would highly recommend to anyone visiting the area.
