Amy's Cafe offers a friendly and welcoming atmosphere where the staff makes everyone feel like family. The food is satisfying, featuring generous lunch portions and tasty dinner options. Standout dishes include the French Silk Pie, Reuben Egg Rolls, Crab Dip, and Chicken Fried Steak with mashed potatoes and delicious green beans with bacon. Although there is a risk of overcooking dishes, the team is quick to correct any mistakes. The cafe has wheelchair accessibility and live music on certain nights, although parking can be limited. The staff is always helpful, providing great service that creates a cheerful environment. Visitors often note how welcoming and caring the staff is, making every visit enjoyable. Guests from various places, including Connecticut and New Jersey, consistently praise the atmosphere and food. The location is off the beaten path, ensuring minimal wait times, making it a worthwhile stop. Despite minor areas for improvement, Amy's Cafe remains a local treasure worth visiting, with a vibe that keeps customers coming back for more.
I just stopped by with a friend and it was nice. I only had a the apple pie but it was delicious😄 had a great server (loved the magenta hair btw 👌). Couldn't ask for more.
May 2026
Enjoyed my Reuben and took half home for the next day. Sweet potato fries were great!
April 2026
French Dip and Turkey Club were amazing. We will be back!
