Penny and a Sixpence is a local jewelry store in Merchant's Square that offers an array of affordable and high-quality jewelry pieces. Customers praise the store's friendly owners, who provide personalized service and helpful recommendations. The everyday prices are described as sale-worthy, making it easy for shoppers to find the perfect gift or treat for themselves. Visitors are impressed by the store's charming atmosphere and diverse selection, ranging from charms and chains to custom-ordered silver pieces. Many reviewers express their delight in discovering this "hidden little gem" and encourage others to visit, assuring that they won't be disappointed.
Run by the owner, nice person She makes some of the jewelry in store
October 2025
Jeff was amazing and helped me pick out some charms and chain lengths, even going so far as to put a chain on himself for reference so I could buy for my boyfriend. Thanks for an amazing purchase and best of luck 💕
August 2025
Super cute store with very affordable jewelry and presents! The owner was super sweet - got the most darling little ring holder for travel for only $3
