Safeway on Bainbridge Island, located at 253 High School Rd NE, offers a convenient and friendly grocery shopping experience. The store is well-stocked with a variety of products, including fresh produce, meats, seafood, and baked goods. The bakery features customizable cakes and cupcakes, while the deli provides made-to-order party trays and hot foods like General Tso's Chicken, which many customers enjoy. The floral department offers exclusive Debi Lilly Design™ products and personalized services. For added convenience, shoppers can use the Order Ahead service to pick up baked goods or groceries, and the store now provides Grocery Delivery and DriveUp & Go™ options, catering to busy schedules. Staff members are generally friendly and helpful, with some going out of their way to assist customers. However, a few reviews mention that the store can sometimes feel complacent or lack certain items common in other Safeway locations, though staff are usually willing to help with special orders. The produce department has received mixed feedback, with some customers finding it lacking, while others find it easy to navigate. Overall, Safeway on Bainbridge Island is a reliable local grocery store that balances convenience with friendly service, despite some occasional shortcomings.
It's Safeway, always overpriced, but not as bad as Whole Foods prices. Maybe Whole Foods prices are justifiable given the quality of their food 😅
August 2026
FRUSTRATION! unable to READ the discount prices right next to the product saying that one must purchase multiples. My corrected eyesight is fine. Safeway's labeling is NOT! Returned 4 products today!
May 2026
I go here daily. I like it and the employees are great
