Coin Cradle is a well-stocked coin and bullion dealer with a very nice variety of items. The staff is described as very knowledgeable about coins. Many customers report the people as nice, respectful, welcoming, and friendly, leading to great conversations and a comfortable experience where they learned something new. Several reviewers received fair or good prices for coins they sold and were happy with the offers, finding them reasonable and more than fair. This has led customers to plan on returning and to highly recommend the business. However, some reviews present a different experience. A few customers felt the gentlemen were not helpful, outgoing, or accommodating, especially to those less familiar with coins, and gave off a shady vibe that made them uncomfortable. It is noted that there is no negotiation on prices, which some feel are well above other local dealers. One reviewer suggests having a clear idea of what you want before visiting.