-
January 2024 by TheseKlownsKrazy AsFuq
Decided to have GodFathers Pizza, so we drove from Renton to Fife for THIS pizza. We got pepperoni pizza slices & it was gross to the point my stomach is STILL queezy. Like what changed? The sauce? The pepperoni? The dough? I've never had a pie or a slice from THIS location that taste like vinegar or like it had way too much soda in the dough. We were highly disappointed having drove so far for THIS disgusting pizza. I didn't even eat my 2nd slice due to how it tasted as I was afraid I was going to throw it ALL up. GodFathers pizza at THIS location has gone down the drain.
-
January 2024 by Sherry Hodges
I've placed orders online here twice, both times when i went in to get the food ( at the projected ready time" they"claimed" it just came through the system so I've had to wait for them to cook it. Update... got my pizzas and they were blackend, i really should've just left they tasted as bad as they looked.
-
October 2023 by Aaron Maruska
No longer serves Taco Pizza at this location. Given such few Godfather Pizza’s left the Seattle-Tacoma area definitely a big letdown over a popular favorite. Guess you live and learn.
-
September 2023 by Greg Polkinghorn
Just wish they had the taco pizza at this
-
September 2023 by J M
Good service, they do
-
July 2023 by Armando Osorio Cruz
Special
-
June 2023 by Starling D.
Error made on order. Manager did remake at NC. Was delivered new pizza that pretty much a raw pizza, dough not thoroughly cooked cheese barely melted.Such a shame as GF had been a great pizza place n very few left.Someone mentioned men's room smelled like pot.Guy at counter wearing headset had to remove them to interact with public.
-
June 2023 by May-Raquel M.
I'm giving this Godfathers pizza a 4 star due to the pizza that was served to us piping hot and piled high. Just like we like it! Customer service were excellent . There are 3 boys still in high school running this pizza joint. I would've given this place 5 stars but their cups was so small and the edges was sharp enough to cut our lips! Owner could get better cups, bigger napkins and decorate the place a bit like how it was in the 90's and bring back the salad bar . Overall really good pizza ,fantastic customer service and its clean.
-
June 2023 by Marissa F.
Great pizza! Loved the taste and the crust was perfect. Great customer service from the beginning. We went during non busy hours and really appreciated that. Quick service and I loved the new updated place. Friendly and family atmosphere. I would highly recommend stopping by if you are in the area!
-
May 2023 by Rita M.
We moved to Spanaway about two years ago. Godfather's is our go-to when we have a pizza craving. Always a good pizza, well prepared, and hot on delivery. And very good customer service!
-
May 2023 by M. B.
Godfather's Taco Pizza and Humble pie are my favorites! Off da chain! I came all the way from the Chi!!!
-
March 2023 by seth
Staff is very sweet for being so patient with my needy aunt's ❤️
-
February 2023 by Clayton J.
The single star title of "Not Good" is the best description of what I experienced. I grew up on Godfather's and in the 90's in Seattle, the locations were numerous. In the suburb city I grew up in, I'd have to estimate we had at least 7 locations. The pizza was a game changer. This thick crust heavy topped pizza wasn't matched. A single slice was nearly a meal, and you could easily eat yourself sick because the taste is so flavorful, you just don't stop! At its peak, you would see sport teams, families, couples, etc. Locations were flat out packed, and you didn't mind waiting 45 minutes for your food. A few years ago, I read a review from a man from Redmond that drove here for nostalgia. It was at that time I knew I needed to make that same drive. When our pizza came the excitement was short lived. The crust was thick, but airy, it also had about half, if not less of the toppings I expected. After the first bite, I didn't think I was eating Godfathers, it tasted like Chuck E Cheese. This place was dirty, We had to clean our table and I watched others do the same. When I approached the counter to get cheese and crushed pepper a customer was upset, they got Styrofoam cups, The staff advised they were out of clean cups.Here is the problem. Either you stock enough cups so this doesn't happen, of you bus the dining room and makes sure the limited cups you have are clean. This was just a failure. The pizza was terrible, the memory is tarnished, and it was not only not worth the drive from Bellevue, it wouldn't be worth the drive from any distance.
-
February 2023 by Dave H.
Always great pizza. I drive 55 miles each way to get their pizza! So good. Service is on point as well.
-
February 2023 by Tara Y.
Love this location! The employees are always kind and welcoming. Ingredients are fresh and pizza comes out hot and melty! My husband and I built a tradition of coming here every Valentine's Day - a pizza treat we never regret.
